Gibson and smith r all solid players but hardy a senior all u hav 2 look at is look at hall now he is a class winger and one of the top try scorer why cos senior is on his side...donald class last year this year nothing so far...the reason is senior mayb not has much now but the bloke is a world class centre and has the abilty 2 pull 2 players 2 him creating space and that is why we need 2 go out and buy 2 class centres,one 2 replace senior when he retires and one 2 replace Gibson,and i would get rid of Gibson and keep smith has in my view smith gives us more opitions

Ok, first of all, Senior is playing really well this season, regardless of what some muppets on here say. I think he possibly has another season as centre left in him. Hopefully one of the kids will replace him then, but I do agree about the other centre, unless Smith really does make it his own.

You have some valid points, but please use full stops and less text speak as it is so much easier to read.


Oh, and welcome!!!!!!

I'm still not 100% sure about Gibson. Since his return he has been largely anonymous. He has been alright, but has not showed any signs that he has more to offer. I really hope he can find something to push him to the next level and start making some real in-roads into defences. He is a lot more assured than Ablett in the centres and for the reason of stability alone he is probably the best option at the moment, but I personally want to see Smith have a decent run there.

Senior has impressed me this year and I must hold my hand up and say I gave him an unfair amount of criticism during last season, but have never been so happy to be proven wrong.

Tend to agree with this.

I do too. I think yesterday highlighted a big mistake made by the club in dropping the lad for the previous two matches.

he is solid,most have not disputed this. however thats all he is, a solid SL player

Maybe brad godden could extend his stay, class act, even made francis cummins look good, GH also put paid to him when he was due a deserved pay rise.

thought he bought senior myself

So godden was not worth a new deal? senior could have complimented him in the three quaters, hetherington doing it on the cheap again, hence this debate

both were left centres,a choice was made

You are correct. I also agree with you about Ash. I can remember watching him at Salford a couple of years ago thinking, "wow!" Unfortunately he got injured that match and I think that could be the tale of his career.
He is solid now, but spectacular? No. I think we could be away at the end of his contract.

Who would have been cheapest at the time, Challenge cup winner, (although senior was) grand finalist who had played for australia, or the bald bloke who put bj mather on his ar*e on grandstand while playing for GH's other team.

time has proved it was the right decision

The younger man was the right decision. Its not even about who was cheapest.

Given age & the then future, your right, think we've gone off on a tangent but it does not hide the fact the money is in the bank while we are watching 3rd rate play for the best rl club in the world!!