maybe you would like to enlighten everyone as to what " not making it" means rogues,as your statement would imply that hundreds of current sl players "haven't made it" would it not?
macca is without a doubt a sl quality player and will be also when he moves from the rhinos
imo he is on a level with logan tomkins who is also a sl standard player but not in a top side like leeds or wigan

To be fair, make it means holding down a regular first seventeen spot, playing each game.

At times McShane has most certainly made it, but the coach wouldn't back him when required, so a bit of an enigma.

His fate isn't sealed. He's 23.

superleague.co.uk/article/29164/ ... ane-up-for Still with Leeds, on transfer list waiting on a fee.

superleague.co.uk/article/29164/ ... ane-up-for Still with Leeds, on transfer list waiting on a fee.

I can see him ending up with us.

We may as well take Diskin back.

I think Diskin's place is secure.

What are you going to pay for him with?

Quite simply his face didn't fit at Leeds. He never got a decent run of games at 9, any creativity and kicking game was coached out of him. He didn't get a fair crack from the sounds of it.

If he's been paid in pies you must be miles over the salary cap.

Me personally? If so I resemble that remark.

I hope McShane is quickly moved on now. Don't want to see this linger on too long and he's still skulking around headingley in new year.

Wonder how much we paid for Aiton and wonder how much Gary will want for McShane.