Would you like him to stay? I've not seen enough of him to form an opinion to be honest.

When he puts the effort in mate i really like him and he could be a real impact player for us but with the off field drama and the effort the club have gone to get him here and keep him happy i think it's best if he went.
Of course like you say if the issues were resolved and the rest of the squad were happy then yeah keep him by all means as long as he toes the line and puts 100% into everything.

Heard a rumour that GC Titans have put a bid in, our choice for player swap with Luke Bailey or money

tvoc won't like me saying this, but I'd bite their hands off for that player swap if Bailey genuinely wanted to come over. Not sure whether he's laid his rep ambitions to rest though.

A four prop rotation of Peacock, Leuluai, Bailey and Bailey would be the best in the league by some distance IMO.

How? When there is no guarantee that Peacock will come back the same player yet, IMO Saints would have 2 props better than any of them.

There's also no guarantee that Perry and LMS will fire for Saints either or that Graham won't be "burnt out" after another gruelling season and tour dowm under.
At the moment nothing is guaranteed especially who will be better placed squad wise.

Andy, whilst there is no doubt that Luke Bailey would significantly improve our front row options, stating that it would be the best 4 prop rotation in the league by some distance is a pretty big statement. I'd say that Warrington (Morley, Carvell, Wood and Harrison), Saints (Graham, Perry, Puletua and Emmitt), Wigan (Fielden, Lima, Coley and Prescott) would all have something to say about that.

So get off the fence and give an opinion if you disagree with his statement.

Coley and Prescott. Guffaw.

and warringtons didn't look so clever in the two league games when we had a fully fit pack.

pmsl

We played most of 1 of those without JP aswell.
They also were'nt the "world beaters" everyone made them out to be last night either.

Bet they will all be there helping to demolish Knows' Road at first available opportunity.

Hope for Leeds yet: it would be sweet to get revenge over Warrington.

I remember a few years ago AP did a league of the top 4 or top 6 head to head. I think Wire would be low down on that if someone could be bothered to do the leg work.

Ok, I disagree with the implication that that set of Leeds props would be far and away the best set in the country. Saints 4 would be at least as good if not better, Warrington would be equal and Wigan would be roughly on a par. I have assumed that Lima and Bailey would be like for like, which I think it fair given they both have international caps, although Bailey not for some time.

Interestingly on Coley and Prescott, Coley has stats as follows when compared to Leuluai. Almost equal on metres, 10% more drives, 150 more tackles, 20% less missed tackles, 6 more errors and 12 more penalties. I'd say overall they compare roughly equally with Kylie making less errors and giving less penalties away, but Coley working much harder.

Prescott compares well with Burgess too (as their teams 4th props respectively) leading in all the key stats, but having played more games than Burgess, 21 to 15.

You might Guffaw and think that Coley and Prescott are crap, but the evidence says otherwise, unless you concede that Leuluai and Burgess are crap too?