The Blease appointment was more important then the next coaching appointment IMO.

I'm coming round to Rowley being my first choice if I'm honest. I've read some stuff on BA and his coaching style and I'm not sure it fits.

But Id be happy with either with who's available.

Some of the best appointments in Super League have been relatively short, it's the quality that matters. Look how Murray, McGuire and Holbrook all got their clubs turned around in a short space of time. It's that type of appointment we need with Blease already looking for the next guy if the NRL come calling. Sound's like Arthur is available and could be in position relatively quickly. If that could facilitate some new front rowers so much the better.

I think Rowley is the favourite.
It's always a risk bringing an Aussie over.
Rowley is proven in SL and can seemingly get the best out of a rag tag bunch.
Probably what we need right now.

Willie Peters would be my number 1 choice, but that's not gonna happen.

I know it will be unpopular as it's old boys club, but I would also be looking at Danny Mags as assistant.

In answer to your question, Jim, I'd be happy with either Rowley or Arthur. There's a certain seductive alure in bringing in a head coach from the NRL, and he's clearly achieved quite a bit in the toughest RL competition in the world. My only concerns are the usual ones around homesickness, not knowing the ins and outs of the English competition etc. In terns of Rowley, while I get peoples opinions about him not coaching at a big club, I don't buy into them. I've really enjoyed watching Salford play over the last few years and if he can replicate that (with a far bigger budget) at Leeds, we could have something special. I suspect we'd also have a much greater chance of keeping Rowley at the club than Arthur if we started to see success on the field. In summary, despite the wow factor Arthur would bring, I lean slightly towards Rowley.

Exactly my view Arthur.
Heart says Arthur.
Head says Rowley.
I'd be OK with either tbh.

Of course the coach needs to be top drawer, bags of experience, been there, done that etc. But we need the next perm coach in now. An interim writes this season off and puts us back to the beginning from next. Arthur certainly meets the criteria and is available. So does Rowley, and if he makes the move now, fair enough.

Demetriou is still a leftfield choice; he's familiar with English conditions etc. and has a point to prove after Souths. He was heralded as the golden boy of coaching just a couple of years ago. Has his star fallen completely..?

Jason Ryles is sometimes mentioned in Aus but another assistant, and I think we need an established head coach now.

Sounds like Arthur is interested at the right price/opportunity, and Rowley sounds like he'd also consider, so perhaps this is a straight shoot-out between the two in reality.

Arthur has been interviewed, apparently

Yes I read that article and whilst he was a players favourite his style of play was let the forwards drive it up until they`re knackered and resist bringing on the subs as long as possible.
Most teams found the Eels out by defending against them until they ran out of gas.
Sadly we don`t have the forwards who can play that style of rugby.
I still think Lee Briers and or Jason Ryles might work.
Other than that get Wane in until the end of the season and take it from there.

Sounds like Brian Mac. Presumably he's ruled out by default.

Wonder if Arthur would be interested in an interim role until the end of the season and then Rowley from next year. If Rowley did want the job but doesn't want to leave Salford mid season it may suit all parties.

Danny Buderus says in the talk to the players (where jjb speaks for 6 minutes and Buderus speaks for 2) 'the games always been won on the advantage line', that's all that needs saying on the failings of smith philosophies

I saw that and thought exactly the same

Figures

Firstly would Arthur want to come over just for a few months as a stand in and probably would feel insulted by that.
If Rowley was contracted in advance for next season and Arthur was successful we potentially end up in a worse position if Rowley fails.