I am not so sure it needs breaking up. But why can we not use Burrow as the impact interchange, ala Roby, rather than have Diskin?

I think from an RL point of view its frustrating to see a team do a good defensive set, then cock it all up for no reason on the 5th

I don't buy this Clarke hates leeds thing. He provides generally good objective analysis of the game. There are plenty of times when he picks out what leeds do better than any other team in SL, and other things in our favour, but people are too blinkered to hear it

I agree, I actualy like the sky line up and think they do a great job

Listen close enough and you'll see what I mean. I agree with you generally, and think Clarke gives a decent analysis. But he doesn't seem to like Leeds. Like I said listen close enough and you'll hear what I mean

I understand what you are saying but why let out a big groan of dissapointment then say ''thats the 2nd time now that leeds have had a penalty on the 5th tackle !! '' ?? I'm sorry but a commentator should not be making such comments. I thought he was out of order.

thought mcguire was awesome!! he is a quality scrum half.

bang on!!

I would agree with that and I particularly like the last bit.




You don't want much do you.

11 in Total:

Interference at the PTB - 3
High Tackle - 3
Ball Steal - 2
Not Square - 1
Obstruction - 1
Offside - 1

It's only may and we have contender for biggest load of crap on message board

"I have stated before this side now needs breaking up - part of that would be one of Sinfield/Burrow/McGuire going." Unbelievable crap


No we have a new winner by some distance

One of Roby strengths is his defence - Burrow does not give the defensive stability Roby gives - imagine if Burrow defended in the middle - he would be permenantly concussed.

One of the reasons I think the squad need shaking up is the integration of new players - it must be very difficult coming into a set up where the rest of the players have been playing together for 6/8 years.

I'm not dissagreeing on breaking up certain points. But I don't see the rush for breaking up just 3 players, when all 3 are versatile enough to move elsewhere. Had you mentioned more across the squad then fair enough.

Andy Roby's defence is poor to be honest. He is as much a one trick pony as Burrow, in that his assett is running at people and breaking the tackle.

Don't agree at all.
Why would you get rid of one our best players.They were good enough last season to the main prize,so what's changed this season?

Agree totally with that. We look a better team no doubt when Ali's on the park. He's a huge player for us if we are to win anything this year. We miss another top class 2nd rower as i posted earlier.

Don't agree at all with getting rid of one out of mcguire burrow sinfield, but out of interest which one are after getting rid of and why?