Agreed on Broadbents defence, no concerns atall with it, every player misses tackles and Tupou has ran through and around much more established centres many times.

Broadbents defence was excellent up against Anthony Gelling last season, handled him better than a lot of expierienced players have managed over the years.

The Briscoe bashing on here is horrific. Bet the same people would be trying to kiss his a** if they saw him f2f!

Like your kissing his now spouting off like its still the 2015 T Briscoe?

For the first time a quite a few years, we have genuine competition for places and depth specially in the pack, so Tony smith Type rotation can be done and if players are not hitting the standard then yes we can drop them and give someone else a go. Thats not a bad thing, too much since 2017 have we had no choice but to go every week with what we have, now we can be more selective, out if form your out, have to wait for your chance again.

My point is it's round 1 what did anyone who played yesterday warrant to be dropped if we were half way through Season and some players weren't pulling there weight for the team then fair enough drop them but after 1 round drop someone for basically not having a bad game is ridiculous.

If it’s round 1, you should only be dropped for something totally stupid like, oh I don’t know, sticking your hand out at a kick off when we’ve just scored, giving them the ball in our half....

I wouldn’t drop Sutcliffe for that, but I would let him know such half dness isn’t acceptable. Compare that with the way Broadbent took the interception.

We go with the same squad unless someone is either injured or newly available, but I would play Smith as a ball handling player in the middle, moving Sutcliffe back to left centre.

The “well he didn’t do anything wrong so can’t be dropped” is a poor excuse, even after round 1. Seem to remember Matt Adamson dropped for the 2004 GF after one out off form game and replaced by a young JJB. We need this philosophy other wise we except the mediocre. Mellor T Briscoe were very poor, so yes even after round 1 drop them or at least give them a warning that performances like that next week and they they will lose their place for round 3.

In other news Sean Wane announces his England squad next week how can we be name an England squad for the WC in November now, and we wonder why we gave not beat the Aussies for 50 years and are never likely to again.

For me Mellor and T.Briscoe didn't really do anything that drastic to be dropped wouldn't say they were our best performers but like I said it's round 1 players need to get up to speed of things before we judge performances and make rash decisions of not picking a player after only 80 mins of rugby.

I thought it was good that all our bench came on and made a genuine contribution,it isn't often you can say that.

Its only a train on squad not the actual squad.

Agree with all this Jim

Myler looks really good when he pushes up into the line in the opposition's 20 and he certainly knows how to pick a final pass or even get onto the end of any breaks and to score himself, I suppose that is what he was renowned for as a half back playing at his best at the Wolves whilst playing outside of Briers who was the controlling half back.(A bit like he is now whilst playing behind Gale, even though he's playing at full back)

Defensively he was at fault for giving Johnstone 10 metres room on the touchline side (Although T Briscoe was also at fault too) When IMO his job is to only give a speedster like Johnstone 5 metres and to take him out irrespective of if he passes the ball inside to a supporting player.

Martin and Mellor certainly need to offer far more in attack than was evident yesterday from them both especially with Sam Walters chomping at the bit for a role in the 17

I was really impressed with Cam Smith when he came on and he would be in my starting side each week at 13

Broadbent was also very good in attack although he did miss a couple of tackles, although Bill Tupou is a very good centre and has ripped holes on his edge against more seasoned pro's than Jack

There might have been an argument to play A Sutcliffe on the right and Jack on the left, where he’s more used to.

What I would say is that despite some defensive lapses he is adding more to the team going forward than most of the rest of the side.

This is again why I question re-signing L Sutcliffe - he seems a popular lad but he doesn’t get in my 17 even now when everyone else is fit, never mind about next year.

I’d be giving Jack a run on that left edge at least until Hurrell is fit again.

This site "Mellor did nothing and should be dropped next week"

Super League website "Mellor Top Tackler"

Who knows best........i wonder.

Good as that is we need a back rower who does more than make the tackles that come their way, make some impact with the ball.