IMO he should have been, he quite clearly chucked the ball in a aggressive manner into the crowd, hence potentially causing injury to a speccie, which could have led to crowd trouble. Like also said it ain't the 1st time he as done something like that.

Tomkin's touching the ref was IMV no different to Webb's so should result in a letter from Redhall & a fine.

Do you think Calderwood shoud have been sent off when he did the same for Leeds against Wigan or, as someone else has said, Lee Smith in the cup game a couple of years back?

Isn't it good that the contributers on this thread, mainly from just five miles down the road from me, can contribute without being banned or have their posting deleted?

Southstander.com - the home of free speech!

I do recall the alleged Calderwood incident, however having been present at the Smith incident in the cup game, it what IMV no way as bad as the Hock yesterday.

Hummm !!!

Yeah, and after that game he bit my hamster's head off!