Plus when Ali crys off after 5 minutes we will be in huge trouble, I'm hardly optimistic now.

Thackrey has been shocking the last couple of weeks. In normal circumstances TS would be justified in dropping him. But, given the fact that he has only 1 out and out prop in the 18 his decsion is bordering on the insane.

incredible over reacting going on here

for what its worth i would select bailey over thackra every time

i have no concerns about taking the selected forwards into the wakefield game, without thackra and bailey

the team selected from this squad will beat wakefield

Thats what counts

Playing devil's advocate he has lost the ball at crucial times in the last two weeks which were both major contributing factors to us dropping 3 points.

True, but I cant see why Smith would drop him when he's got 2 other props injured at the same time.

Has anyone considered that when Smith did this to Thackray at the beginning of the year it really galvanised his play?

As Joihn DH has said, Thacks form has dropped off the last few weeks. Maybe, just maybe, Smith knows his players better than the knee jerkers on here. Maybe Smith realises that Thacks need tough love and this may just spur him back to some decent form in time for trhe playoffs?

What were your comments when Smith dropped McDermot for the 2005 Challenge Cup Final and went with only two props?

I never understand what Bailey offers to the team. IMO opinion he makes less metres than he should, never offloads and his disipline at times is shocking.

Thats different though, the cup final is a 1 off game. If dropping Thackray gives him a kick up the backside and gets him playing better its probably the right thing to do. Plus McDermott was better than Thackray.

is this not a cup final? we simply have to win. to go in with 2 props is stupid,given what happened in cardiff. smith is a and roll on the day he gets his p45

no its not a cup final.

No we dont, we only need a draw and thats only if Bradford beat Hull.

Its a different team, at a different ground, in a different situation. You cant possibly compare the two.

Then you're just as bitter as DISA for some reason im not quite sure why.

See tads post. Its no different.

We lose Friday becasue of this tactical nonsense, and we finish 3rd. Much harder position than what we could have.

The fact that this tactic failed so badly in 2005 should make the issue this Friday even more apparent for everyone to think.

thing we smith is that everyone makes mistakes but he doesn't seem to have learned from his.

I feel we should have given Burgess a run out even if it is from the bench.
Ali playing is a risk.
Thacks must have been dropped for disciplinary reasons.
Having said all that we should be better than Wakefield who are only playing for pride and to finish their season with a win against us.

What a totally ridiculous comment. Everyone knows that spending 5 days a week watching them in training and spending most evenings reviewing footage of their performances with your other coaching staff is a poor substitute for watching the game once, live and maybe, some weeks, a re-run on Sky. You're just embarassing yourself with your crack-pot views now Gareth.