Nope , he looked up when about 3 feet off Smith , definite penalty

As regards Smith , he's had a good season for us , isn't 1 st choice in any position , but probably 2 nd in several

running at full pace and he looks up at 3 feet and you expect him to stop? really? I rest my case

No I don't expect him to stop , I expect him to either challenge for the ball ( by looking where the ball is ) or not tackle until the opposition player has caught it

Don't you actually know the rules ?

so you don't expect him to stop? you've answered the question then. he couldn't stop.

I was pleased leigh came up but Christ, some of their fans are really special

I agree, he came up with game winning tries in many big games (including 3 GFs) and only left the club because he was loosing his place in the team anyway. I would expect him to get a response on similar lines to Ali.

To tell the truth, I was a little embarrassed by both the cheering when he got sin binned and the disrespect Segeyaro showed him. When Segeyaro scores crucial tries in multiple finals then he can carry on like that.

Oh my God I think Ive cracked it! A Iestyn Harris trophy made of wood, and if we win we burn it like the Ashes!

Thought not.

Truth is we could play Leigh (or any other SL team - until MW fixtures are announced) either 2, 3, 4 or 5 times in the League(s) & then once in the CC - please correct me if I've miscalculated.

It was a penalty was it not ?

End of

As for special , well , many Leeds fans ( and one particular ex player it would seem given his twitter and media rants ) have thought themselves that for many years , and you can include uncle Gary in that as well

But as this season has proved , you aren't

All the best , enjoy your visit to the LSV next year

it was a penalty. no doubt. what I sais was it wasn't intentional. reckless maybe. and i'll take one bad year after 16 years of success anyday thankyou

that 40/20 he did in 2008 was as crucial as the one Sinfield did in the play off semi against Saints last year

Looks a bit of a [iMong[/i-rel to me, not quite from the Albert Kelly family tree but certainly a bit of a [iwindow licker ![/i

Some very classy "banter" on this thread.

We used to get Pie eaters dwelling on here till they grew up .Now we are getting there poor relations