How many years has Richards been here? is it 3?

If so you could add Sullivan to that list then. I think he played up to end of 2003, and was a quality winger.

Sullivan only played '01. Although looking up Sullivan I did stumble across Paul Newlove. He was a cracking Centre!

Really? I thought he played in 03, my bad.

Cummins should really be included in the Wing debate he did '01, '02 & '03. Although I'd say Richards would be a better shout.

rlhttps://www.slstats.org/t4/St.+Helens/2002/Summary.htmlrl

My memory is appalling so I wouldn't be able to tell you from memory but he disappears on the 2002 squad list. I'd say that was pretty reliable.

And Richards has been here 5 years. '06 - '10

Using the NRL criteria of 2000 to 2010 there have been Jason Robinson, Anthony Sullivan, Alan Hunte, Tevita Vaikona, Brett Dallas, Darren Albert, Leslie Vainikolo, Brian Carney, Gareth Raynor, Henry Fa'afili, Marcus Bai, Mark Calderwood, Aaron Murphy, Scott Donald, Pat Richards, David Hodgson, Chris Hicks, Ryan Hall and any two from the aformentioned would make my team ahead of Cummins.

Of Wakefield? Really?

Radlinski
Robinson
Lyon
Hape
Leslie
Barrett
Lam
Morley
Cunningham
Peacock
Sculthorpe
Furner
Farrell

Anderson
Fielden
Lowes
Furner/Radford


(bit or Wigan bias there I know )

It's a fair cop, I was thinking Justin Murphy at Les Catalans Dragons but inexplicable wrote Aaron. Never mind these things happen in the off-seson, it's why I never post in the depths of winter.

Ah..... so we're using that much less traditional "Australian Decade" of 11 years!!

Is that like a Baker's Dozen??

Either way, if we're counting Robinson as eligible, here endeth the debate IMO.

1. Wellens - controversial selection but far more consistent over the last DECADE than Radlinski, however much a FB with so little pace may be derided by NRL fanboys.
2. Albert
3. Lyon
4. Senior
5. Vainikolo
6. Pryce
7. Long
8. Fielden (pre-Mason form far superior than anything Morley has done in his second SL stint)
9. Cunningham
10. Graham
11. Peacock
12. Farrell
13. Sinfield (gets the 13 because Faz was more flexible in the forwards)

Bench spots:
14. Sculthorpe: stellar start to the decade but faded through injury
15. McGuire
16. Ellis
17. Hape

Burgess didn't do enough in SL to be included IMO.

Also... if we're following their lead for comparison purposes... if there's a player you really really like (Billy Slater), but a better player in their choice position (Darren Lockyer), you can just put them somewhere they once stood for a match or two. Talk about trying to crowbar players in and making sure they don't miss out. I'm not saying he hasn't played a match or two on the wing. I can even remember a few myself. I'm just saying, as fantastic a Full Back he may be, they've picked him on the wing purely so he's in the squad and if Billy Slater is one of the two best NRL wingers of the past 10 years I'll eat my hat.

I feel a bit sorry for Wellens thinking the only reason he doesn't make my squad is because of Radlinski, so I might put him down as the Coach. Then at least he doesn't feel left out.

They also seem to have put some Union Playing, Public Toilet Dwelling, Drink Driving, Money Grabbing, Pretty Boy in the second row, but hey, it's their team. Who am I to judge!