What relevance does that have in a debate about players being released for mid-season internationals?

And the reality is Leeds vs Batley last year got much more than a England vs Wales/Scotland/Ireland/France game would get played mid season alongside league fixtures.

leeds v batley got a lower attendance than the last time England played Scotland or Ireland and only got a couple of hundred more than the last time England played france. In France. this despite being included on the season tickets.p

Yes and as pointed out that Ireland game was a World Cup game, wouldn't get anywhere near that number outside of World Cup and Scotland game was a double header with Aus vs NZ. So very inaccurate portrayal of what those games would get played in the time period suggested previously.

so what your saying is that international attendances for well planned, well marketed international competitions far outstrip all SL attendances and massively outstrip the crappy 8s attendances.

I agree. More well planned, well marketed international games is a great idea. we don't need the poorly planned, barely marketed international games in some northern backwater or the atrocious 8's like some idiot said earlier

I'm not interested in seeing England play Scotland, Ireland or Wales. I would like to see us play some proper matches against France if they could get their act together. Playing them in France initially on an evening under the floodlights with a hostile French crowd would probably help make them a bit more interesting/competitive.
Part of the problem is like us and Australia. We need to play them more to get used to laying them and scrape a few wins.
France need to play us more but the games would get boring before they get the win unless they pull their socks up sharpish.
If we could have regular competitive internationals with France I'd definitely be interested.
Unfortunately I think the only think that might kick start it is if in 5 years Canada has managed to get some local based players at Toronto and also other SL and NRL clubs.

Nope what I'm saying is major events like a World Cup attract bigger attendances. Beating Ireland on the way to hopeful World Cup glory means something....beating them in June in a single match wouldn't mean anything and you couldn't market it to convince fans otherwise.

And just getting better than some SL games or the Middle 8's games isn't a measure of success.....internationals should be getting way way way more. England RU don't play Australia at Twickenham in front of 80,000 one week and then play Ireland in front of 8,000 at Twickenham Stoop the next.

Yes there is a big difference between well organised and marketed meaningful international competition and the half-d one off in some parochial backwater that was suggested earlier.

I agree more well marketed, well planned meaningful internationals are the way forward.

better than pretty much all SL games. But yes you're right being better than the ty 8s is no barometer of success. Leigh couldn't even give away as many tickets as we're sold in avignon.

but you know what the biggest difference between international RU and international RL is? in RU they actually play both Australia and Ireland. Whatever we get in a match versus Ireland is infinitely better than the 0 we get when we don't play them.

No it's not if you're splashing out lots of money on players having central contracts, this super dooper world class marketing and going to bigger venues with increased costs and not getting the suitable money back in ticket sales.

England RU can play both Australia AND Ireland because both are proper contests. Everyone knows England vs Ireland at RL wouldn't be and just because you keep saying "proper marketing" doesn't mean you'd be able to shift tickets to fans for this game.

All RL clubs have that problem. Not even our wonderful Leeds Rhinos can survive on ticket sales alone. in fact very very few sports clubs of any persuasion can survive on ticket sales alone. it's so rare it seem moronic to bring such a possibility up. Fortunately there are other revenue streams such as sponsorship (are there many RL clubs sponsored by bigger companies than Gillette) TV revenues. not only that but there are other benefits besides money such as visibility and exposure which is far far far far larger for any international than Leeds V Batley.
Ireland have beaten new Zealand in RU once in their entire history. Scotland RL has a better record against NZ than Scotland RU.

we have sold 25k tickets for a game between England and Ireland. just because you don't like and want to disregard it doesn't make it any less true.

I'm not disregarding it, I'm pointing out it had the luxury of being a World Cup fixture, something it won't have mid season. Only in Smokey dream world can World Cup game do the same or even similar business as a potential mid season game. Even you can't be ridiculous enough to think the attendance number wouldn't be seriously depleted. That you tried comparing Ireland RU's competitiveness to its RL counterpart suggest otherwise.

I don't know if it's because there isn't a decent RU team around but I was brought up watching RU internationals and with RL league games. The figures you produce for the well attended international league games are when there is no club rugby. If league did a similar thing I would have zero interest in the internaonals would prefer to watch leeds.
I think the difference between League and RU take a six nations for example. There is no competition you can tell the result of who will win without playing, it's pointless. When I watch a RU international the atmosphere is amazing when I watch a league one the empty stadium is embarrasing

10k fewer people watch England v Ireland in WC2000 than in WC2013. 15k fewer people watched Fiji v England. The correlation isnt between the world cup and the crowds. Its the quality of the organisation, planning and marketing.

In 1992 GB toured Australasia in June and July and got good crowds, in October (which was mid-season) 73k watched Australia v GB at Wembley.

Record numbers watched the 1990 Australia tour, played in October and November, which was mid-season, that record was broken in 1994, which was again played mid-season.