Graham Smyth said the credible source is at the club who gave them the information basically lied to them to try keep the clause details quite. He got told last year Summerville had a release clause but then this year the same club source denied it.

Fans don't need to know everything, that's not the point. But, we need to know what's going on following the sales of Gray, Summerville, Rutter. They need to calm the storm. Why didn't they tie Rutter down to a new contract with a release clause next year once Gray and Summerville went... they know he had a release clause and Brighton had bid twice for him a few weeks ago... they've let him go here... they've either seen the pound signs or its gross bad management. The red bull money was meant to keep our best players (bar 1 or 2 needing to be sold). They were Marathe's words.

This offseason was meant to be the settled one with a couple of key players sold and heavily invest, in Marathe's own words after the bomb shell of Gray being sold, to get us the best squad we can to get us automatically promoted.

We've now sold our best 3 players, with only 15 days left in the window and need to bring 4 or 5 quality players in. We are playing catch up yet again at the start of the season with 4 tough games coming up.....

We've only got 19 senior players currently. We've gone from promotion favourites to possible playoff contenders. Other clubs will know we are desperate now and takes away our negotiation power. They will have to pull 4 quality rabbits from the hat and very quickly..

I'm not convinced by Smyth's reasoning. This has happened several times now where he's said he was given the information from a club source, only for it to change fairly quickly. Either, he needs to get a new source, or he needs to stop printing unverified information. Also, I'm pretty sure contractual information is private and confidential, so it's illegal to disclose an individual's employment conditions, so anyone in the media who says a player has a clause or not should be taken with more than a pinch of salt.

At the end of the day, any club outside of European qualification is a potential selling club, this is especially true for clubs outside the top 5 leagues. There's simply no money in these leagues, and they're not very attractive propositions to the majority of players, especially a league as long and gruelling as the championship.

What more do fans expect, really? Yes, we're a big club, but we're subject to the same rules and challenges as any other club in our position. Our best players will all want to leave eventually, and most will have some clause in their contracts. It's just the reality of where we are. Do we really need an explanation about these transfers when it's pretty self explanatory?

I'd rather the club just shut up and get on with trying to sign some players, that is the only thing that will really calm the fans down.

Interesting that we are the second highest club in Europe for player transfers this window.
It`s understandable the fans want answers having been promised an investment in the squad by Paraag in order to get us promoted.
It shows either naivety or negligence not tying Rutter down to a better contract especially as we tried to match the offer he got from Brighton albeit too late.
I agree that we should not be privy to what is going on behind closed doors and the only way to appease the fans it to bring in at least 4 new quality signings hopefully before our next home game.
Failure to do it by the end of the transfer window will be a disaster.

To be fair regarding offering Rutter a new contract, contracts take months to negotiate, so even if they offered him a new deal at the end of last season, they probably wouldn't have agreed it by now. Anyway, I bet most fans wouldn't have expected anyone would pay 40m for him. A lot of fans (not me) wanted to sell him last year when Lyon and Dortmund were offering 25m.

Anyway, it's done and we have to move on. Lot's of hard lessons to learn for all involved, even us fans.

I would have been happy to see him go during his time at the club along with Gnonto.
If we could bring in players with experience for 10/15 million then the days of Rutter, Summerville, Gnonto will be a thing of the past.
My worry is we end up panic buying, spending 15/20 million and we are worse off then we were 2 years ago.
I would like Johnstone from Palace as our next keeper but Farke is too loyal to Meslier
The same goes for Bamford and Piroe who I thought at the time was a good signing but don`t think he fits the position Farke wants him to play.
Play him as an out and out 9 as he is too slow as the10.
Now if we beat the Baggies tomorrow all will be forgiven!

Yep spot on

Mike McGrath confining Leeds are looking at Jack Clarke closely and it’s one to watch

He'll go to the PL. Spending 25m on a player in the championship is probably the equivalent to spending 100m on a player in the PL. I just don't see it happening

Defensively solid but woeful going forward today. Piroe James were woeful. Joseph poor, Gonoto not much better. Still it’s a decent point at a tough ground

I`d have taken a point all day after our last 2 games.
Aaronssen far too easy to push off the ball Joseph not yet physically up to it against solid non compromising defenders, Piroe is offering nothing same with James and as for Bamford we would be better playing Joffy.
Against Boro he lost the ball too many times, botched passes and one shot that went 30 yards wide.
Get rid.
We need to bring in some experienced forward from somewhere.
Not another project at this stage.
The defence was good today though.

only saw the first half as I'm away. I'd have taken a clean sheet and a point too. get some players in next week especially a 10 and 8

We had no idea what to do in transition. Rutter has left a huge hole. You can see the players have lost that swagger and are a bit shell shocked. Midfield and Piroe were clueless progressing the ball. Worst game I’ve seen James have.. Jospeh couldn’t keep the ball.

If we don’t bring in 3 or 4 good players in we’ll struggle to make playoffs it’s quite staggering

There’s so much wrong with this team offensively. We had the same problems the back end of last season even when we had Rutter, Summerville and Gray. As said above, the transition from defence through midfield into the final third is snail’s pace. Poirot should stick to solving mysteries, he should be nowhere the team. He’s turned out to be a terrible signing. My priority would be to sign a genuine left winger with pace. We need the threat of running in behind teams, there’s only James that currently offers that threat. Gnonto never was and never is going to be a winger. He needs to be doing his work centrally nearer Joseph. Get a proper winger, move Gnonto to where Poirot has been playing, and throw Poirot in the skip with all the empty beer glasses and coffee cups. We may see the best of Joseph if we can start getting some decent ball across a bit earlier, he’s not one to destroy defenders in behind with his pace. We’re only gonna see that with a change of personnel, you won’t see it with the current team.

Jack Clarke might be an option with his pace with Gnonto playing the Rutter role.

There's no way we spend 20m+ on a single player whilst we're in the championship