I'd go with a similar team to yours except start Walters and put Delaney on the bench in place of Achurch. Walters was one of the very few good points from the easter weekend and deserves a place in the team.

Hardaker
Briscoe
Watkins
Moon
Handley

Sutcliffe
Mcguire

Singleton
Falloon
Cuthbertson
Ablett
Ferres
JJB

Garbutt
Galloway/ Mullally
Delaney/keinhorst
Lilley/Burrow

I don't feel Walters offers much attacking wise I think Achurch deserve a spot on bench I thought against wakey who poked his nose through a few tackles and I think he offer more although it is just abit more

You're right Achurch did get on top of the first tackler a couple of times on Monday and his size and strength does give him a natural advantage over Walters. However Walters looks like he is giving it his all every time he steps onto the pitch while Achurch does seem to shy away at times. The stats can't separate them but if I was lining up I'd much rather have the less skillful but more committed player than the greater player who doesn't run his weight next to me.

Besides Delaney is to be given a late fitness test so it looks like both Achurch and Walters will be playing anyway!

Achurch offered a lot more than Walters, has to play.

Hardaker
Briscoe
Watkins
Moon
Handley
Sutcliffe
McGuire / Burrow
Galloway
Falloon
Cuthbertson
Ferres
Ablett
Jones-Buchanan

Burrow / Lilley
Singleton
Garbutt
Mullally

Ferres isn't in the squad (injured) and neither is Singleton (dropped).

In which case:

Hardaker
Briscoe
Watkins
Moon
Handley
Sutcliffe
Burrow
Galloway
Falloon
Cuthbertson
Keinhorst
Achurch
Jones-Buchanan

McGuire
Garbutt
Mullally
Ablett

I think Walters has offered far more than Achurch, works really hard on defence and had some strong runs and a half break against wakey if I remember rightly.

Achurch is a weird one, I can remember two involvements from him this year, his try on Monday, and the run for the try (was it Sutty?) against Catalan. Apart from that I can't remember anything else. Maybe It's easier to think about Walters performances as he is 100% effort type of player.

Singleton had a shocker against Wakey,but he wasn't the only one and you knew it would be him carrying the can. Same pattern emerging when Mcshane was at leeds ,and we all know what happened there.BIG MISTAKE!

I agree in part about carrying the can so to speak, but in no way would i say i regret us releasing Paul McShane.

From that selection I'd go with:-

1. Hardaker
2. Briscoe
3. Watkins
4. Moon
5. Handley

6. McGuire
7. Sutcliffe

8. Galloway
9. Falloon
10. Cuthbertson
11. Delaney
12. Ablett
13. Jones-Buchanan

14. Burrow
15. Garbutt
16. Mullally
17. Walters

The only good thing about releasing Mcshane is we got Paul Aiton coming to us and let's be fair Aiton had a slow start at leeds then was out for 3 months with an illness then he was best player we had until got injured but Mcshane I think is a better hooker than we have now?

From the sound of Brian Mac's press conference today, no Briscoe tomorrow so I presume Watkins to the wing and Keinhorst/Ablett to centre.

If that`s the case then I would put Keinhorst at centre and leave Ablett in the pack to beef it up.
On Singleton maybe his confidence has taken a nosedive after getting dropped/rested recently?

Or maybe he's going all out and playing Sutcliffe at fullback with Hardaker on the wing?

Sutcliffe
Hardaker Watkins Moon Handley
McGuire Burrow
Galloway Falloon Cuthbertson
Ablett Achurch
JJB

Walters Mullally Garbutt Lilley

But don't be surprised if Moon doesnt play been ill all week