He damn well helps with improving our attack and try scoring threat so that will do for now. We are trying for hastings but its taking time.

We arnt getting Hastings, even if we survive it leaves us with 4 half backs for next year

He solves the problem of having at least one decent half back!

What would you like the club to do, nothing?

Sorry but Robert Lui is not , what are you basing your opinion on?

Honestly i give up... no pleasing some people

Ok...........

Hopefully Lolohea is shipped out or left to play his days out in the new reserves, Sutcliffe reverts to squad utility if not out, and Myler plays 3rd fiddle to a new game managing halfback/Mclelleand

What I’d want in ideal world is licences so that we didn’t have the threat of relegation to waste valuable cap space on more crap. But that ain’t happening. I’m allowed not to be impressed with the signing or how the club is being managed. We don’t all have to agree. Merrin for me although playing well is a waste of marquee space and what I’ve seen first hand is a bad apple and I’m not impressed with the management and how it’s been felt with.

What we giving up on? Making everyone agree with your opinion. We don’t all have to agree

I would rather wait for next year to get a good managing half back than panicking now buying lui.

You can have whatever opinion you want, and we are allowed to question it.

And actually I agree that rugby league and SL cannot sustain P&R and they should just announce a 14 team SL for next season now - but that’s not going to happen.

What I am questioning is your judgment on olayers, Robert Lui may not be the top of the list of signings but he is far from the dud you are trying to make out. I’ll ask you now who would you orfer to be at 6 for us on Sunday, Liam Sutcliffe or Robert Lui?

They’re not mutually exclusive

It’s short term thinking though. Yes he’s better than sutcliffe. But I’d want neither in reality. And I’d probably rather put up with sutcliffe if it meant we got the required player next year

Not if we got relegated

Signing a player that could possibly keep us up in SL is short term thinking but I’m sorry to tell you that’s the situation were in.

We are looking long term by getting rid of Watkins and Parcell plus hopefully Ferres, unfortunately we are in a relegation battle and short term solutions are needed

Any improvement in the halves has to be seen as a positive given the perilous position they find themselves next season may be too late. 2 halfbacks are needed, he could turn out to be one depending on the recruitment of an organising half. I don’t think anyone’s doing backflips about the potential signing of lui but most can see the current pairing is a shower of .... and the team needs change however small to give them a better chance of avoiding bottom.