Agree. Could do with a season in championship Broadbent

I've no idea who I'd like us to sign, that's the club's job. I was stating what Agar said.

I’d like us to sign Alex Walmsley. I think he’d be willing to come. Saints would sell for enough money.

Not convinced you a are right on both them points. Walmsley would be a great fit.

Broadbent had 2 runs on one he was bundled into touch after getting it 3yds in field any winger would have got the same. Stephens is no smaller than Walker or Webb for e.g.

I agree Broadbent had no chance but he still looked like a boy against men.Let him learn his trade and fill out at bit at Fev and then maybe towards the end of the season he may get a chance if we are short.Stevens isn't 18 until March let him also learn his trade.If he played on the wing now there's a good chance he would get smashed to bits and then ruined.

I’ve said this before, so if Konrad picked up a 6-7 week injury as did Handley in round 1 then you would go with:
1. Walker
2. Newman
3. Sutcliffe
4. Broadbent or A Sutcliffe
5. Stephens or hall

God forbid if we also got injuries in the back row at the same time and L or A Sutcliffe had to play in the pack as well, in which case you’d go with:

1. Walker
2. Hall
3. Newman
4. Broadbent
5. Stephens

You seem to have this huge issue with Evans or anybody being cover in the squad, even if it is one year to allow younger players to develop so they can take the shirt long term.

Good shout, positive post as well. Solution based instead of just moaning all the time.

Would love to sign him, not sure they would let him go a week before the season but would be happy to try. Maybe the club already have

My issue is signing deadwood if it was someone who was going to be a genuine competitor for a shirt then fine.
Evans on ANY of your lists doesnt look any better he's finished done a PT has been.

Walmsley's a great player, who would undoubtedly go well at Leeds. He's not a 'solution' until he signs though. I fail to see how drawing up fantasy shopping lists counts as a 'solution'.

The solution is suggesting somebody instead of saying oh we want a signing because you said we would sign somebody and we aren’t happy we haven’t signed anybody.

If it was a pure fantasy list do you really think he would be at the top? He is a realistic target, I don’t think we could get him but it is at least plausible we could sign him.

It is so negative all the time, oh we want a signing, we want a signing. I simply asked who?

But if Evans plays and gets smashed or we ship 40 points down his side then it isn’t the end of the world. He is disposable at the end of the season isn’t he? Those young lads are people we may want to build into a team for 7-10 years so getting smashed or shipping loads of points 3-4 weeks in a row could significantly damage them couldn’t it.