Sorry, disagree. I don't think any coach could do that with the current side. And I'm not saying that in order to defend McDermott. There were some fairly basic things he could and should have ensured happened today but didn't.

they could be more organised and structured for a start. we looked like a pub team who just turned up and went out

I pointed out exactly why you might not be right, you don't like that though.

Might have a better chance but they've retired, let's get over it and it's not like they're ready made like for like replacements for those players running around.

All the talk about Sinfield and Peacock and another coach.

Question did Sinfield and Peacock + co win a CC under McClennen, under Smith, under Powell?

Seem to recall a SF loss to Hudds in2006 that was much worst than today, losing to Hull in a final, getting walloped by Warrington in 2010.

For the majority of the 21st century we've been dumped out of the cup in disappointing fashion regardless of players or coach. The only who has landed is the cup is actually McDermott. McClennen, Smith, Powell and Lance all failed.

we looked like a team that had given up. 2 points dropped last week, Salford, Hull & Wakey will be on our backs now.... We will finish 5th if things dont change! Ite now time for a new coach!

Not seen the game.

However, overall I don't think there's too much to be overly negative about. I think the current team is decent, but the difference from before is that then we could say ''if we turn up at our best....'' whereas now if one of the other top teams is at their best we're likely to come up short.

We still have a good chance at getting to old trafford and winning, we're second with only the league to focus on now whereas it's guaranteed 2 of our rivals (hull and salford/wigan) will be playing in the CC final.

Better than swallowing any story a 17 year old tells you.

Yep. Tackling was all over. Fatal not to synchronise and hit in 2s and 3s against a big pack. Instead, one would-be tackler was regularly distracted by the support runner on the shoulder of the ball carrier who then made almost endless metres at times.

First crunch game of the season and we have been beaten in all aspects of the game. Unfortunately several of our squad are pedestrian in the extreme. Our pack was annilated in the second half, ferres not fit should never have been on the pitch. Absolutely no venom in our tackling, the hull forwards rolled us over thus preventing any quick ruck speed. We neither had the speed or energy to inflict the same on the hull pack. Briscoe was so poor I felt sorry for him. Surely he can't play next week. Passing the ball across the field woeful, players receiving the ball virtually stood still. If anybody thinks myler will bring anything to this team they are sadly mistaken. Surely a place must be found for walker, even if it's just on the bench.

Erm, no you didn't...

You posted some crap about how the better team won, I agree they did, but nothing about why we could slip to the outer in terms of silverware for another 5 years.

I think the squad is as good as any other in a pretty poor league,maybe wigans slightly stronger when fully fit. If we had a coach who gave the players the best chance to play well a lot of them wouldnt look as poor as they do at present....I wouldnt swap squads with castleford but id swap coaches in a heartbeat and if that happened id be confident of challenging for trophys.

Again, I did. Whilst all you've done is regards lines used season and season that got proved foolish.

Then do me a favour an quote the bit you are referring to as in my old age I clearly can't see it.

Hull pack were too much for Leeds as game wore on, particularly watts and minichello.

Hull were very good. Leeds pretty average overall. Hull stopped Cuthbertson well and Leeds had little to offer ball in hand as game wore on.

Be interesting to see how rest of year plays out but we look too one-paced and with too many average players to threten at year end for mine..

FWIW I think McDermott was right to rest them last week, big test v Wigan on friday

There may not be ready made replacements but you at least A.Try to recruit quality & B.Adapt a gameplan to suit the squad you do have.
Wrt 2006 today was easily on a par if not worse imo.
You say lets get over it now Sinfield & JP have gone that's fine but it's becoming clearer that others need to move on aswell on & off the field.
This "New Era" is going to need a fresh approach fresh ideas & better recruitment.