For the same reason that Warrington will probably never be champions under Tony Smith.

By and large they did react, unfortunately for the club most of the decisions proved to be disastrous. Fortunately Paul Caddick stepped in to save the day. If at the end of the season things are still dire ,then that's the time to take stock of the situation.

But you know as well as everyone else that recruitment does not take place in the close season, it takes place long before, with agreements in place. End of the season is totally the wrong time to take stock and decide from there, as you are as still likely to be regretting it the following season.

When we appointed Tony Smith, and the decision made, but for a couple of players getting in to trouble, Daryl Powell could have been going out as a champion, and irrespective of that it was still our best season in a while. Compare and contrast to this.

At the season end ,it may well be Brian Mac saying I have had enough, time for someone else to have a go.
Also it will be time to make a decision on various young players like sutcliffe. He will have had sufficient chances to prove himself, if he does not improve he will or should be moved on.

I wouldnt be judging young players after this year they've been on a hiding to nothing.

Quite true, like everbody else I am hoping we can get most, if not all of our senior players back in the next few weeks.
Then we can judge the current squad of players. It seems a long time since the season kicked off with a decent performance against the wire. Probably unlucky to lose that game, since then Lady Luck has not smiled upon us.

galloway not up to the task either

Thank god Falloon only on a one year contract or is he really better than he has been playing

Coming into a struggling team at hooker is a tough ask. From memory the great buderus did not rip up too many trees in first year, nor did Aiton. They both had advantage of coming into sides playing much better and with kylie on one side and the amazing freak Jp on the other. Also halves are all over the shop. He is not the biggest but has done some good round the ankles tackles near line to stop tries like buderus used to. Think fairer to judge him and Galloway at end of year if we ever start to play better.

A one trick pony..............The penny is beginning to drop

Wow what a lot of anger!

I never said or suggested that all our success was down to the coach. It is a combined effort. Usually the players rightly take the most credit for success and IMO it should also be the players who are responsible when they fail to produce the expected performances as they are supposed to be professionals. When the usually reliable actor fluffs his lines it is not the fault of the director.

To simply blame the coach for all our troubles is plain wrong. Coaches cannot prevent players dropping the ball over the line, or a high bomb, or a missed tackle not matter what they do on the training field. If half your squad is out injured you have not the luxury of being able to change the side. For most of this season we have struggle to get a full side out for training mid week let alone on match day. You are assuming the coach is making errors when you do not know at all, yet you are not calling for Watkins, Hardaker or Hall to be sacked despite awful performances that you can see for yourself week after week.

Many were critical of the coach when he didn't play Singleton and Garbutt for a couple of weeks yet they were both arguably our worst performing props in the previous game against Wigan (I think) and we did not know if there were off the field disciplinary issues or injury niggles either. When they both did return they again showed disappointing form which rather justified their previous lack of selection.

However despite the long injury list and the poor defense and the errors etc etc IMO had we had a creative game manager on the field and a decent kicker we would have won another 4 or 5 games and be just outside the top 4. (we have lost once by 2 points and by 4 points in 4 other games) We have had plenty of field position and possession despite our form to have won more matches even in the first game against Warrington and I think all would agree our 5th tackle options and decisions have been very poor.

Maybe BM is to fully or partly to blame for the failure to recruit a replacement for Sinfield's key role in the side (ie creative game manager/goal kicker. ) However I am not privy to management meetings and therefore without knowledge of that I cannot agree with the calls for his removal. To put all our faith in McGuire staying fit and in form all season was foolhardy IMO and to expect Sutcliffe to step in to such a crucial role in the event of Mags being unfit was equally foolish.

There are always two sides to a situation and amid all the one sided posting I am just putting another point of view.