I started liking Edwards after his strop at Odsal in 1998. I can't remember who didn't pass to him when he would have been clean through against us, but the reaction was brilliant.

I like Edwards now he doesn't play for Wigan, and let's be honest again, most people who weren't Wigan fans hated him, but 99% of them would have fookin loved him if he'd played for them. He was a dirty get, but he was a win-at-all-costs sort of player, and he did plenty of hard work to make sure he did a lot of winning.

The guy is a born winner, and I'd love to see him back in RL as a coach.

Barrie McDermott was a thug who picked on kids. Also the best prop of his generation. I don't recall many Leeds fans booing him.

One of the dirtiest players of his generation.

Loved him.

See above comments on Shaun Edwards.

Sam Tomkins
Ben Westwood

Martin Offiah
Shaun Edwards

and
Jonny Wilkinson
Gavin Henson
Just in case they feel the need for an easy pension

Silly argument. Wonder how many would want Bailey if not already a Leeds player.

Sam Tomkins, Lee Brierley, Ben Westwood ... Would have them all if they enhance the team's chances of winning.

Matt Calland.

Was it? I always had Graeme Bradley down as the offender, could be wrong.

to many to name who I wouldn't want but Ben Westwood gives 100% and
Graham is a class prop and young Sam a golden talent even though he's from wigan and I admire most players just for playing the game. Yes I have rose tinted glasses, anyone who plays for the Rhinos I like and will support everytime even Ian Kirke.

I thought it was Robbie Paul.

Can't recall who it was but Bradley, Calland and Paul all played in that 'four seasons' game in '98 when Harris really burst onto the scene.



Lee Brierley? I remember Mike Brearley, not sure he'd have enhanced the Leeds pack in the seventies though.

Ditto. Conversely I never minded Phil Clurke as a player.

Always considered Edwards to be tough (as in being able to take the punishment coming his way) rather than being dirty himself. Of course people will point to the takle on Clyde at Wembley but that was for me largely out of character and more a desperate, mis-timed act rather than a premeditated, 'I'm going to knock his head off.'

To be honest I don't really care whether they're likeable or not provided they do a job on the pitch.