3 hookers into 1 position.....

Dont think Mcshane has done enough for me at this point, that said he hasn't had the opportunity really and he has shown glimpse's of his talent too. The Jury's still out on him.

Don't really think mcshane has had any real opportunity this season, I hear that it was Northampton ru after disco? Just heard that at work, don't know where he would end up playing in union?

Blimey, not sure at all...obviously Hooker is not a like for like position in the two codes.

Scrum half i'd imagine but not sure he has the pace for that.

In the centres maybe?

From the best possible source, he is not going to Hull FC.

that's the obvious position, but agree with your concerns on that one - whippet quick scrum halves seem to be in vogue at the moment like Care and Ben Youngs.

Well...the best possible source would be Diskin himself.

So....if he is your source and he says he's definitely not going to Hull it kind of implies he's going somewhere else....otherwise your 'source' would have told you he was staying at Leeds??

How much would it cost for such delight?

I have pointed out in several different threads in the last few months that Matt Diskin is defaintley leaving us at the end of this season! Buderus is on a two year contract despite YEP saying its only a 1 year deal, with Bedsy moving into a player coaching role in 2012, Leeds put Liam Hood on a fulltime contract for the next 3 seasons last month which is yet to be announced, and have been told from someone inside the club that its Diskins final year this year. Hence the reason weve got McShane to step up once Diskin leaves at end of 2011 and Hood to replace Buderus in 2012.

I like the assumption on here that people assume McShane can week after week fill Diskins boots.

I am yet to be convinced.

Diskin along with his group (Sinfield, McGuire, Burrow, JJB) will all need replacing in the not too distant future. No doubt. Like nature, the team needs to evolve.

But you have to be careful of not cutting your nose off to spite your face.

All rumours are rumours.

What happened to TMFMISL to Cas??? Lead balloon. what a shock.

Knowing the IQ of Diskin, his big decision is likely to be peas or beans.

Think I had a dream similar to that

LOL at Matt who has taken the pi$$ out of all the rumours on his tweets.