Can you watch a match without "anti-leeds specs"??????
We got some calls tonight but none more than went against us!!
What about the trip on mcguire??
What about the giants not square??
What about jjb getting ruled knock on when the giant's player kneed the ball out of his hand's??
You see we can all identify calls against our team or the team we feel are hard done by!!

I can only apologise. I have re-read your comments and accept that you have judged it from a neutrals point of view and you do have a point. I have had a drink and maybe have been a bit excitable.

He was rubbish yes but he wasn't biased to one side, we also had numerous decisions go against us but then one of our tries shouldn't have been given. Get over it we would have won if we had a PERFECT referee which is NEVER going to happen

Is Ian Smith allowed back at your gaff now that Mr Anderson has taken his dummy home?

He's been making up for lost time this year. We've had him 3 or 4 times already this year.

So that will be after a certain Mr Anderson has left then yes?

Ref was shocking tonight BUT for both teams. Hudds had hands in the ruck all the time and Silverwood hardly picked up on it.

The standard of refereeing really is crap, even the video refs are getting things wrong.

Yes totally agree shocking again for both sides and not much better from what i saw last night either.

The Diskin try was Monsieur Alibert's decision. Another baffling decision from the Frenchman.

Not really.

1)Peacock didn't play at it.
2) The last contact before he picked it up was off Wild.

Haven't yet seen the replay, but it made me scratch my head at the time. Accidental offside for mine.

I thought all the officials had poor games tonight.
But one good thing that Silverwood did was to penalise the Giants ( mason ) i think for moving off the mark.
It made up for the earlier error when he penalised McGuire (I think) for holding Wilde when he moved forward about a metre as McGuire was trying to get back to marker.
Saints are masters at doing this to win dodgy penalties.
No matter how bad the ref was he wasn't the one dropping the ball in our 20 metre zone.
As has been said mistakes do tend to even out over a season.

didnt complain about him last week.

NEXT!

What about Where Sinfield had a clear facial on the floor and the ball knocked from his grasp. Knock on given. then in the next set Hudders lost the ball and a penalty given to them? Works both ways.

What about the trip on McGuire when he would have been clean through?

The Diskin try was completely correct. Do you not know the rules? Huddersfield knocked the ball on and it bounced off a player, that player not playing at the ball. Therefore play on.