It's not really is it, it's voted for by fellow coaches and they probably appreciate how good a job he's done this year with a squad that's half part time

They won 3 games and got relegated, which is probably what most expected them to do. It's essentially an adult participation trophy.

And Wigan finished top which is what most expect them to do, so should Peet not be nominated?
I'm happy to defer to the other super league coaches on this, but obviously you know better

Wigan also won a WCC, a CC and league leaders shield.

And with the squad they've got, being handed the WCC by the wigan ref, and the cc being moved earlier in the year, I'm pretty sure people had them favourites for the treble.

So why is it embarrassing for Eccles to be nominated by his fellow coaches?

Dumb from Tai. Wire are coping easily with KR's kicking game. Absolutely no need.

Incredible call by Moore. Staggering. He's guessed, pure and simple.

Ran over and clearly had no idea where the ball was, so how's he sent it up as a try?

And that`s why the rule needs changing.
Even Burgess didn`t think it was a try.

My predictions thus far.
Hull KR 20 Wire 18 KR by 2
Wigan 30 Leigh 10 Wigan by 20
Wigan 24 Hull KR 10 Wigan by 14
Yes I know I posted this after the game last night but posted it on another site Friday morning, promise

As retirement games go, I can't think of too many worse than Matt Moylon's game today.

Looks like Klien has got one wrong there for Storm even the bunker missed it.

I always think thousands of fans singing a little respect bloody creepy!!

lewis has cost rovers 2 trys by not passing and going on his own

I swear Wigan would be about 3rd or 4th without French.

Nsemba passing his HIA seems dodgy to me, he was out cold.

of course he never passed it. not a hope

We may not know for some seasons yet. He’s a real X factor player, as is Jai Field. They also have a second rower that can run faster than most of the Leeds team. Take those three out of the team and take a couple from the pack and they may finish 2nd or 3rd.
Hull KR battled gamely but they never looked like scoring a try. I thought Willie Peters made a big mistake with his tactics near the opponents line. Why would you die with the ball or go down a blind alley through the hands when you have two wingers as big as Burgess and Hall up against the two Wigan midgets ? They never tested them with a cross kick out wide on the last tackle. Absolutely baffling. As for Nsemba, he probably guessed right when the ref asked him how many fingers he was holding up.

Absolutely. I thought being knocked out was immediate removal from the game, how has he been allowed to continue? Any contact with the head is a penalty due to duty of care, but a kid who got knocked out is allowed back on the field? Horrific

Nonsense. I have it on good authority that he was examined by Dr Nick Riviera MD.

He was either out cold and should never have returned to the game or not out cold and just trying to milk a penalty/sending off, I'd like to think the former but......

I thought Lewis, as good as he is with ball in hand, was found out a bit defensively. Granted he won’t be the last person French makes look silly.

His (Lewis) performance reminded me of Gale in 2017. Wasn't allowed to dictate the game as he had all season and didn't show he had the where with all to impose himself. A couple of poor decisions with ball in hand, possibly borne out of frustration.

Wigan just ground them down and counter-punched brilliantly.
Not a game for attacking it was a defensive masterclass from both sides punctured by a brilliant bit of skill from Bevan French and were also unlucky / lucky (point of view) to having another chalked of for being within 10.

Thought HKR played into the hands of Wigan and let them dictate the flow and pace of the game where there was only going to be one winner.

I'd agree with the non testing of the Wigan wingers but if you bugger one of those up your not catching any of their back three from any distance, maybe thats why they went the way they did, bit more conservative.

Thought KR battled very well but were a little bit one dimensional going forward when it really mattered. Enjoyed the game though, full credit to Wigan, they are a very good side. Forward pack is exceptional and French is in the form of his life. Surprised if he's not off back to NRL tbh... Wigan have done very well to keep him - something Leeds have kept failing to do in recent years.

Interesting movements at Salford from 2026. PR to become DoR with assistant Kurt Haggerty taking over as head coach.