I'd say this year he's performed better than Clark and McIlorum, and that's not criticising those 2 players either.

Does the list go on? Really? Because the next ones on that list are the likes of Houghton, Pelissier etc.

Again, I'd take issue with the assertion that he's currently an average SL player and that he's easily replaced.

He isn't no Buderus, not many are, Roby is no Buderus either. Is that really a bad thing?

He is a damn good player for us, and absolute miles better than McClorum, etc.

I actually agree with you that he is easily replaced, but not because he is bad, just that there are many hookers out there who can do a job for us, due to the players around him in the team. But I still think he is better than most of the players you will no doubt tell us are better than him, and if you can accommodate that, why settle for a lesser player to replace?

Yes and you need to start listening to them for a change.

Absolutely - Aiton's a real catalyst in our forwards' go-forward. I dread it when he's subbed, let alone let go...

i asked pete smith and he said watch this space so something is going on with aiton just have to wait for announcement ?

He's been as good, or better than all of those players this season.

That didn't take long

Better than the 2015 Darryl Clark? By an absolute street. Clark has been awful this year and absolutely outplayed by Brad Dwyer, who began the season at London FFS.

Aiton offers you more going forward than McIlorum, who is arguably a better defender.

Carry on with your list though. Better than Ian Henderson? Yes. Better than Luke Robinson? Yes. Better than Danny Houghton, Shaun Lunt, Adam Milner? By a mile.

So there are one, arguably two hookers in SL who are better players on their 2015 form than Paul Aiton. I think you may need to refine your definition of "average".

aiton doesnt sound to good www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/s ... -1-7377273 think if we wanted to retain him we would of offered a new deal imho

aiton doesnt sound to good www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/s ... -1-7377273 think if we wanted to retain him we would of offered a new deal imho

Quote HAILESY="HAILESY"aiton doesnt sound to good www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/s ... -1-7377273 think if we wanted to retain him we would of offered a new deal imho'" We only offered Hardaker his new deal in August last year when it was due to end October this year. We are not in August yet, and Aitons does not end until Octo re 2016. I took from that interview that he will be staying, and a new deal given.

Quote HAILESY="HAILESY"aiton doesnt sound to good www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/s ... -1-7377273 think if we wanted to retain him we would of offered a new deal imho'" We only offered Hardaker his new deal in August last year when it was due to end October this year. We are not in August yet, and Aitons does not end until Octo re 2016. I took from that interview that he will be staying, and a new deal given.

GH is just waiting on Cameron Smith to say yes