If I were a Wire fan I'd be beyond frustrated. I don't watch him very often, but never find myself impressed when I do. Last night I thought he looked average at best. Was that performance at the lower end of the spectrum of his performances?

I've read that Benji Marshall (& I'd guess Widdop too) has twice weekly sessions with a kicking coach.
The quality of the Dragons kicking game was one of the major differences between the two sides & an area where we always seem to be inferior when compared to the teams down under.
A major lesson to be learned there as has been evident for as long as I've watched top class RL.
One other thing that I really noticed was that the Dragons players always played the ball correctly, if they can be made to do that why can't our players?
We, the Rhinos, are some of the worst culprits & it really bugs me.
It is solely down to the referees.
Re Thaler I thought he reffed the game pretty well, both high shots started on the shoulder. Yellow card? Maybe? But he did get the Atkins reef wrong.
All in all a very enjoyable start to the weekend's games.
I'm not too bothered about tonight's game but I'm looking forward to the proper game on Sunday, let's see how good Saints pack is against the Rabbitohs.

70% of his performances are like last night, then the other 30% he'll be a world beater, that is why i'm frustrated with him, he has it in him but more often than not he flatters to deceive.

An enjoyable game, thought simms looks a good forward , I am assuming that he won't keep on spilling the ball every time he plays.
Not certain what Mylers problem is, as a young player he looked like he would develope in to a top player.
Unfortunately he has not progressed , if anything he has gone backwards. Time to go out on loan to a championship side?
As a rhinos fans but also a rugby fan it was pleasing to see penny coming back to the wire and looking better for his travels .
A bit more composure and the wire could have and should have won.
On balance they will finish up in the top four play off.
I have a slight fear that the Aussie teams will make it three nil, whilst I like the Australians and enjoyed a month in Australia watching rugby. They can be a pain in the backside when they beat any british team.

Myler needs to go to a club lower down the league, either on loan or for a couple of seasons. He'd be playing every week and there'd be far less pressure on him and so I reckon he'd get some confidence back.

Neither are Warrington.

Not getting why people think last night shows that SL can compete with the NRL.

St George were 11th on the NRL ladder. They were playing away from home, in what for them was a pre-season game, against a team that will most likely finish in the top 4 of SL.

And yet they still dealt pretty comfortably with most of what a one-dimensional Warrington threw at them.

I'd love to see fixtures like these take place on neutral ground when both teams are in the middle of their seasons, although I suspect the results might represent something of a wake-up call for SL.

It's funny how normally it's oh top teams in Super League would get hammered by bottom clubs in NRL. When it doesn't happen its, oh they are only a lower team in the NRL.

The top four in super league can compete with the top in the NRL. The problem is that the bottom four of the NRL can compete with the top of Super League. That is because the NRL is much more even. But a top four shouldn't be tarred with the same brush as our bottom dwellers.

Looking at that St George side i dont think they will miss out on the play offs this year.

I agree with Gotcha,i have always been of the view that our top few sides can be a match for the NRL sides.Yes they would be favourites in most of the games if played mid season, but the gap isn't that big.Warrington shot themselves in the foot last night if they didn't make silly errors at the play the ball drop the ball in there own quarter, and throw the ball away (Atkins springs to mind) they would have won imo.

The problem with the teams in SL, even the top teams is they lack quality and composure in the key pivot positions. I reckon the top teams in SL can give any team in the NRL a game because physically and defensively they're pretty even. However, the lack of craft from the halves and the hooker is evident in most SL teams when you compare them to their NRL counter parts.

That first "high" tackle on Penny was brilliant. High on the chest and that was it, Penny's pace helped propell him in the air. The Benji Marshall yes was higher but I've seen worse. Otherwise out of the three games I thought that would be the worst but a cracking game

Plus, George Rose, what a hero

Totally agree! As a Manly fan I have a lot of time for the big guy!

George Rose gives us all hope...

Yep.

'Another Pie and a Pint Please'...