so would you rather have a try allowed for cheating rather than sticking within the rules?

How far offside was Donald by the way? From my vantage point it was impossible to tell.

On the whole issue raised, it's a difficult one. If the referee has consistently failed to penalise an offence, despite having say 20 opportunities to do so, surely it's reasonable to assume he's going to let the 21st one go as well. And how many tries are scored after an incorrect play the ball? That's cheating as well.

they should all be ruled out then!!

if the ref calls it, its a penalty/try/scrum whatever, referees don't win or lose games end of story!

I agree with both you and LP.
Afterall ref's don't miss tackle's,have a poor kicking game and try impossible offload's and by the same token if 1 incorrect ptb,marker's not square,or tackle inteferrence is penalised they ALL should be.

Steve Ganson is a frustrating referee for one reason above all the others. He's inconsistent. Those occasions where he is determined to let the game flow (ie almost zero penalties, no knock ons or forward passes) regardless of the players actions often results (not surprisingly) in a poor spectacle.

Re: Schofield V Laughton. Laughton would tell the press when questioned about Schofield's future at Leeds, that he never sells good players let alone great ones but as we all know what a coach says in public is not necessarily what they say in private.

You should have read it all. You have missed my common sense in all this drivel!!!!!

Booooooo

Gerrroffffff

Loada rubbish.

Bloody rubbish Leeds.

Hetherington OUT

Mclemonn OUT

Sack the board

Booooooooooooooooooooo

At least some posters give these lads there support. What a wonderful passionate and true supporter this handsome fellow is.

God I feel smug right now.

the greatest results not the greatest players

how many would be in an all time 13 ?

Most of them.

off the top off my head

ettingshausen
grothe
bell
dyl/senior
atkinson
holmes
cliff lyons
pitchford
ward
PEACOCK
clues
LAUITITI
batten

no 8 bit of a blank but just couldn't put crooks or jeffasaurus fior services elsewhere though dean bell included

Do you honestly think the majority on here will have even heard of Ray Batten let alone seen him play, let alone realise he was fourth in line for the John Holmes minute silence.

Arthur Clues makes it but no Lewis Jones?

First name on my team sheet would still be Mick Shoebottom.

Holder of the record for the number of tries scored by a forward in a season until a certain Mr. Hanley came along? Heard of him but, regrettably, not old enough to have seen him play.

Speaking of Hanley, he should be in the all time list, as should Adrian Morley.

How about Mick Clark ?

Close but that was Bob Haigh although he can thank Ray Batten for most of them.