I thought he's done alright so far. I think he regularly makes decent metres, is hard to knock back, takes several defenders in the tackle and hits fairly hard too.

As Sgt Wilko said, solid, not spectacular. But I think you'll get consistently solid performances from him.

He needs to improve, not good enough at the moment.

Awful OP

I thought he lacked go forward and made a couple of fundamental errors against Huddersfield. Never the less, I feel it is bit early to be writing off just yet

agree with this. He will go ok and get better as the season goes on.

He looks unhappy here.

On the Aussie prop scale he is more cross than cuthbertson. Time will tell though

i think he has started ok, gets through the graft.He is obviously a no frills prop up the jumper style total opposite to Cuthbertson but not sure we need a team of front rowers tossing it around anyway.I expect him to improve with s proper hooker to work with and dryer tracks.The big problem here too is a lot of people expecting him to take over from JP but he was a freak once in a generation front row able to carry a pack on his own,the majority of forwards look average in comparison.

He's appalling.

Needs to improve 100%

This

He certainly hasn't impressed the way Cuthbo or Garbutt did....but maybe it's because he has arrived into a 'different team' ....(was he a ever a 'pack leader' down under?)

With the loss of our freak prop, Peacock, and rule changes, you might consider our esteemed coach has even LESS excuse for not using his bloody sub forwards.

Agree with everyone saying give him a chance.

He moved countries to join a treble winning team but has been stuck in to a total make shift mid table looking one at the moment with absolutely no direction or leadership.

I'm sure he will improve as we do