I'm not 100% convinced that it was a penalty for the tackle.

Seemed pretty fair to me, and should've been 'Play On'. Getting smashed to the ground is what happens with 'Hospital Passes'

Was it not high? I've not checked my sky+ yet.

Not in Rugby League it wasn't.

Watmough hit Burrow in the head, no ifs or buts about it. Straight on smash with his tricep. As Burrow had just reached up to take Peacock's shocking pass he was about as tall as he gets on a rugby field.

Robinson (unlike most Aussie refs) doesn't appear to ask the video ref for his input when such incidents occur. Given who the video ref was yesterday that could have been interesting.

Good to see Watmough find Burrow at the end of the game and apologise to him.

He's been knocked out more times than Mr Giles from Buffy the Vampire Slayer.

Just out of interest, if the ref penalised the Manly player for a high shot (and it's not clear he did), then it would surely have been a card of some kind.

Personnaly I don't beleive there was much wrong (although aiming your swinging arm at where a normal sized person's chest is and using it as an excuse for hitting Burrow in the face is not really a defense).

i think the pen was for off side

Just like last week when this same referee put Westwood on report (5 matches) but no card, Mogg penalty but no card and Fakir not even a fooking penalty (1 match) let alone a card of some kind?

Like I said last week about Robinson, he's a typical Aussie Referee, anything below the temple is fair game.

But what I seriously don't get is whenever a player is injured in the NRL the referee's almost always uses the breathing space to ask the video referee to at least review what has caused the injury if there's a possibility of foul play.

If Robinson has done this in the last two weeks I must have missed it.

Hope we never see Jason ' Barry Manilow' Robinson again.

I thought it was a fair shot - what was Whatmough supposed to do - he simply ran over Burrow - no swinging arm a hit not unlike a few SBW put on a couple of Leeds players.

The pass was simply appalling - summed up Peacock's contribution tbh ie more of a hinderance than a help last night.

A tackle around the head is still a tackle around the head regardless of the quality of the pass and should still result in an automatic penalty.

I sure the ref was getting help from upstairs later on in the game, he certainly had his finger in his ear a lot

That'll be to lesson the whining noises coming from the whinging poms, especially Ganson.

A bad pass does not technically give the defender the right to smash someone in the face, and because Burrow is smaller than most does not give the defender the right to smash him in the face. The angle from behind the tackler clearly shows him swinging his right arm - that's a "swinging arm" I believe.
I did think Burrow slipped a bit (but then you would try and duck if soemones coming to kock your head off), but how many times do you ever see a guy penalised for a high shot that knocks a player unconcious without him getting at least a yellow.
If you replace the Manly player with Adrian Morely and Robinson with Ganson and you're looking at a straight red.
I don't think there was much intent in the colission but I can't understand why the ref gave a penalty if the tackle was okay?

Either that or he's a folk singer in his spare time.