read the thread title carefully.

Of course we've heard the legends you named but I suspect few of us saw many of them play.

Besides, legendary as those names are, their deeds pale to the deeds of the 2004-2009 teams however misty eyed the passing of time may cause fans to be.

1.Harris

2.Hall
3.Carroll
4.Senior
5.Bai

6.McGuire
7.Burrow

8.Peacock
9.Diskin
10.Peacock
11.Furner
12.Ellis
13.Sinfield

14.Ali
15. Buderus
16. B.McDermott
17. Morley

Are you taking the mick or what?

We've never had a player called 'me'.

I don't even think the chinese have heard of rugby league.

It was Simon Irving that told me John Bentley's nickname was Bentos.

I KNEW you'd be the person to reply to that. When I saw it, I instantly thought "tvoc will reply to that when he sees it".

I called SkyBet, explained the situation, asked for some odds. They told me that they didn't know what a tvoc was and that I should stop calling.

me too, though I went to ask Neil Summers about it and ended up talking to Irvin.

Neither Eggbox, Irving, Bentos or Jon Bentley told me Summers' nickname.

True story.

I think it was Donna.

Ah yes the whacky world of RU scouting.

feels like a game of blankety blank

cheers have you suffered as long?

gary connolly another who would have been picked on deeds elsewhere

In my days as a Chairman/Director of Rugby I came very close to signing him for a national league side. Also took junior teams to Cleckheaton.

very imature post. pointless when you have mainly teenagers posting.

Well I saw plenty of these legends play and no way do their deeds pale. My understanding of "Greatest" in the thread title is with regard to their rugby skills.

If your sole criteria for judging greatness of a player is according to the number of cups they won then I prefer to stay misty eyed. By your criteria of Greatest you will have to include the likes of Kirke & Bailey.

Memories of Sinny lifting a Cup for me will fade but not the many great rugby moments that those legends provided - they are there for ever!