Thought you didn't rate Atkins?

Not a view I can recall expressing on here. It's fair to say I rate Shenton the higher of the two though.

I recall you said that until Atkins did the stuff against the big teams, you wouldn't consider him. If not, my bad.

Cos he wants to, Dummy!!

Did Huddersfield Rhino tell you to say that?

whom is he?

I can't believe someone would mix me and thee up when we agree on so little anyway.

For mine, Shenton is already a better player then Atkins, has proven that he can play on the right hand side as well as left, and is younger. If we were to go for one of them it'd be Shenton for me. Personally I wouldn't want Atkins, although I do see that at times he's a more than useful player.

N.B. Younger by 9 months

It is lovely to be right! All those who doubt my source - being a certain player lol!

Shenton if he comes then, as he should, no real Westerman like aliegence to Cas and dislike of us.

Not for the 1st time tonight i watched Cas with an eye on Shenton and found myself underwhelmed but far more impressed with Owen.

I assume Cas moved Shenton to left centre to make him their main strike weapon this year? If so, he wasn't exactly an outlet.

Whilst i don't doubt your source(at least until proved otherwise) i'd say yer wide of the mark re-shentons loyalty to cas he stayed when they were relegated and could of left for nothing having a choice of a few clubs.

I agree but to be fair cas had to do a lot of defending especially in the second half and if we were to get shenton or atkins i'd expect them to be better playing in a better squad.