Having watched the try again on the Super League show, how on earth can Thaler overrule the touchjudge who was stood inches away?

Not seen it was it a try or not?

i've just watched it and completely agree, it wasnt Thaler's finest hour friday night

No Try

The in goal judge was also nowhere near so it couldn't have been him making the decission

I promise you he went to the in goal touch judge and then awarded the try.
Thank fook we came back and won.

No at first glance (thats all they have shown) it appears as though Smith sheparded it out, Giants player looks as though he touched it after it went out of play

May need a view in slow motion

It was a shocking decision, hodgson didn't even look like he grounded on the line or in touch nevermind in the field of play!

No wonder touch judges don't like making decisions, when they do they get over ruled.

I'm just glad we won and that decision didn't cost us tbh.

It makes me wonder if they call the forward passes and offsides and just get ignored.
Again i don't think Cummings should be in control of the officials because there's no improvement other than fitness in their performances.

It wasn't a try. I have always rated Thaler but he was appallingly bad on Friday. I agree on Cummings.he has to go.the overall standards have dropped since he took over

I agree mate, the refs are infact getting worse, I actually wish Ashley Klein would come back from the nrl, things are that bad!

Tad you have more chance of Michael Jackson rising from the grave to ref a game than standards improving under Mr cummings.

Proof positive that the "jobs for the boys" and "Old Blazers Network" mentality is alive and well at Redhall.

To say it was a shocking decision you don't sound so sure.

Did you actually see the incident?

Yes mate I did, and from what I saw it didn't look like even grounded the ball, whether it was in the field of play or in touch, hodgson didn't to me look like he thought it was a try by his lack of appeal/celebration!

IMO of course I just can't see how he could give it as a try, that's why I think it was a shocking call!

What your view era?

I was on the opposite side of the pitch but Hall said after that the in goal judge gave it.