1. Buderus
2. Watkins
3. Delaney

BJB did nothing wrong, and Bailey was OK though wasn't on the field for long enough. Peacock had a good last ten minutes and Sinfield, who had a poor match, at least was excellent in extra-time.

Burrow and McGuire were shocking. Couldn't believe how often they took the wrong option and killed our opportunities. And we maybe made 2 offloads in the first 70 minutes, which must be a coaching decision.

How have you worked that one out?? I don't think fans realise how little impact the coach has on the players kick-off. You forget everything the coach had mentioned pretty much. I can hardly see Mcdermott saying "Listen lads, don't offload under any circumstances"

Maybe he said "Don't panic, keep composed and keep possession" which would be quite useful consideirng the amount of ball you have lost with outrageous offloads this season.. Maybe just maybe it was the players who chose not to offload.

1. Jones-Bishop
2. Watkins
3. Leuluai

Burrow and Bailey were good and Sinny came into his own towards the end. Thought Delaney was ok.

Hardly noticed Buderus - don't think he did anything special. McGuire was very poor and certainly not up to his standard before his injury. Webb was the poorest player on the pitch. Why he didn't tackle Chase when he had the chance is anyone's guess.

1. BJB
2. Buderus
3. Bailey

Semi finals just need winning, does not matter how you play.

BJB
Bailey
Delaney

I put Buderus as 1. because he was, as usual, always the first in the kick-chase and hassled Cas into errors with his defensive speed, including the knock-on from which we scored. He was good attacking out of dummy-half as well. Unlike Burrow there's always the possibility that he'll pass the ball when he's running into traffic.

1. Peacock
2. Bailey
3. BJB

1 BJB
2 sinny
3 beds / jp

some poor displays and choices made

thought we were a very average side and if cas had anything about them they should have won

Every game just needs winning, it's not good playing awesome and losing.

My top 3 were:

1. BJB - Looked dangerous everytime he got the ball and made some great clearing runs
2. Peacock - No penalties or mistakes (that i remember) just yards and tackles, yards and tackles
3. Burrow - We may have only scored one try but burrow was lively and dangerous the whole game and put cas on the back foot many times with darting runs.

I am not the biggest burrow fan but I thought he had a good game today

BJB
Buderus
Bailey

Burrow had a decent game imo lost count how many times he and Buderus broke from the ptb and looked for support that did'nt f#8king arrive.
I also agree with Al Rhino winning is EVERYTHING in these matches.

1. Buderus - He got through a lot of defence, especially in his first stint. Good running from dummy half in second stint.
2. BJB - Excellent clearing runs
3. difficult to come up with no.3!

A generally poor display I thought.

Watched it on TV - glad we didn't have to put up J Davies!!
How poor is Ray French? In first half he described Chases' penalty kick to touch which landed in play and bounced into touch as 'a fantastic kick'!!! What planet is he on?
I hope the grammar police aren't watching I'm not sure about that apostrophe

BJB
JJB
Peacock

TMFMISL
BJB
SIR KEV

1. Buderus
2. Kirke
3. McDermott & Lowes