He’s not good enough at all.

don't think anything has been decided yet. I think he deserves a contract, maybe just for a year and let the young lads develop a bit further.

He’s been very very solid so far and much better than expected. Definitely deserves a year.

In your opinion, but in most others opinion, he’s been massive

He's been praised by the players. I trust their opinion over yours, which is excessively negative about everything.

I'd be happy if BodeneThompson got 1 year for next season he brings experience and hard graft to our pack and with losing Cuthbertson we have 2 spare overseas spots so could still go into market for another world class overseas player if they become available to us.

He's surpassed expectations, but I'd only sign him if nobody better is available.

Not for me , we have grafters we have experience we need bigger impact a line breaking Prop if we're going after another BR then an off loading type. We need to utilise our overseas spots on quality.

League express says we'r in negotiations with him to stay next year.

Agreed

Would he actually be on the quota given that Toronto effectively went bust? For what it's worth I like him. Competent in all aspects and if you have 17 of those you are hard to beat.