Quote: Clearwing "There are always reasons behind poor performance and the ones you list are perfectly valid. But to assume automatically that Sutty's defence will be inferior very much depends on which period of Zak's career you wish to focus upon.'"
For me we shouldn't even have the question "is his defence going to be as good as Zak"......it should simply be "is his defence going to be good enough", I have no reason to think it won't be. I see nothing in his abilities/attribrutes that are an obvious weakness in that regards. His main weakness at the moment for playing FB is just his lack of experience in the role but that surely will improve with time, a preseason under his belt there, and more games.
If the prerequisite for a new FB is that he has to be as good defensively as Hardaker then we'll be searching for one for a long time.