It isn't really relevent who played worse, as Achurch wasn't the worst, and therefore I would just be deemed as having a go at others. But to be fair I will answer, and IMO Sutcliffe and Watkins performances were worse. I am in full agreement on the errors Achurch made, but that just completely overlooks the good stuff he did do, and had someone like JJB for example done his same stats there would be praise rather than over the top critisism.

Like I said, is he value for money, no he isn't. Do I think it is worth perservering with him, no I don't. But he certainly is not the player portrayed on here either, just the scapegoat chosen for those who do not want to critisize other players.

And for the record, there was no comparison with Ablett above, it was a statement based on a particular example of Achurch on Friday, as tackle watching, something Ablett does often, and therefore used as an example. I could have used other players also, who do the same at times.

Looking at the tries conceded our defence is still very much a joke. I don't care how many injuries we have, or who is on the field, some of the feeble efforts (in particular players not even getting into a position to defend) are appalling.

I'd also add that Golding should never have been asked to take the drive on our line that led to Sts try. A heads up play from the acting half would have been a dummy and run for himself, not passing to one of the smallest players in a position where all that would happen is him getting mullered.

This is the most annoying thing for me, the defensive structure is all over the shop and has been since Widnes away. Its been mentioned a lot but the ruck is really terrible and needs fixing up badly.As poor as our attack has been for the most part, if we had been better in this area we wouldn't be down where we are right now imo.

What struck me was that all it took for Sts to break the line was a smaller player to run towards the Leeds defence then stop and start again. The defence looked like it was playing musical statues.

As an aside a friend at work watched the full game yesterday and he was raving about Lilley. Mind you as a Sharks fan for the past few years he has been watching Jeff Robson at 7.

Its selfish defending, or at least self-preserving defending that is costing us
Players are pushing off far too early and asking far too much of their inside man, often overcommitting to an outside threat
Worrying thing is its players who are usually quite reliable in defence, there has been a lot of time this season when I have been shouting 'where is he going!' in Ablets direction, who seams to think his inside defenders are superhuman