Quote: RAFLeaguer "I call bull on a few of your points. Tomkins has been garbage and nowhere near lived up to the price tag. If Warriors have been happy with him they'll be cartwheeling to matches next year with Tuivasa-Scheck. When he has been injured they have looked no worse for having Lolohea at 1. He's had no support game through the middle, instead playing like a 2nd 6 and he's probably been the worst defensive fullback in the comp. He hasn't been on the level of the Munsters, Tedesco's, Whitens and Moylans without even considering the top level 1's in the NRL like Slater, GI, Boyd, Dugan and Tuivasa-Scheck.-
Next point about Shaun Johnson. Headless chicken? Really? He single handedly dismantled several defences with his step and dummy when they looked out of options as well as offering them structured play and a cracking kicking game.'"
Okay thanks for that. Like I've said he was injured for a lot of this season, hence explaining a large part of his form, he's barely had chance to get going and it still remains true that NZW don't play him correctly. It's infuriating to see him never get the ball in a decent position, (as Johnson just overlooks him) his passing has still been excellent and he's still set up or at least had a hand in several tries this season. I'm a Melbourne fan and if you think that Cameron Munster is a better fullback then that just shows how utterly ridiculous you are being.
I was mainly talking about 2014 in regards to him apparently being a failure but okay.
About Johnson, that's why I said half the time. He is either on fire or clueless I was just making a comparison with his international form. I completely disagree with him offering structured play!
Tomkins was never going to live up to the price tag as NZW are a poor team that Tomkins just doesn't fit in with.
I'll not bang on about it anymore because I don't really need to justify how good Tomkins is as he'll do that himself when people actually start watching him again next season. Although they probably still won't because some fans are so blinkered they can't see talent when it's right in front of them.
Tomkins and Hardaker will both play for England and the side will be better off for it.