Baldwinson certainly didn't look like SL standard for us last season.

He may come good but it's hard for young props to make a mark at top level without going past the 19 years cut off point.

A bit like halves really. There are the very rare exceptions but in general props need some time to really develop strength. It's a gamble that the cap, competition structure and squad limitations make very difficult to take. Baldwinson looks like he has the frame to fill out, I still don't think Singleton has and I'm not convined he will get any better.

Singleton looks like he's one of those players who can only play prop but hasn't got the basic size and strength required to be a great one. He could become a reasonable workhorse if he gets fit, but I suspect part of the reason for looking a tad overweight is to try to make up for basic lack of bulk. Wikipedia has him down at about 15 st 8 - if right that's really small for a prop nowadays.

I agree. I thibk that he will always like the size to be truly effective in the modern game nor does he have a frame that can be developed sufficently to carry more weight.
Hence why on the surface Mulhern looks the much better long term prospect provided that he has the bottle for the fight.

Surprised foster was not kept.