Right choice if correct. Ok JP ran his blood to water at times this year but equally Brough has done the same if not more in terms of controlling Hudds attack and kicking for them. With that and the fact they won LLS only fair he should pick it up!

Yeah it's just the best player of the year these days. Isn't about a big tough guy doing loads of big tough guy stuff and stuff.

Rubbish. He wasn't picked as the likes of Myler and Chase were deemed a better option and there were lingering question marks about his attitude. So, like a good pro he set out to win the coach over and fight for a place.

What?

He didn't?

Chucked a strop and withdrew his eligibility?

Proved people doubting his attitude well wrong. Good lad. If he hadn't he'd almost certainly be playing in the world cup for the country of his birth and his lifelong residence. As I see it both parties have lost out.

Brough did the understandable thing after being snubbed by McNamara. Not that I think he should have ever thrown his hat into that ring (if he even did) having represented Scotland in the 2008 World Cup.

Will never be convinced about Brough. Great player when things are going his way & his pack dominates, but a liability when not. Then again that's what I used to think about Shaun Edwards.......

I think he's deserved it. When you watch their games he's been the one that has made them tick with his kicking and broken field running. He's been thr driving force behind their improvement.