Charnley is overrated IMO............good SL winger playing in a very good SL squad.

Hall over Charnley every time

John Atkinson was a brilliant winger in his day - although no Lee Penny - classic G1.

Those days were pretty different generally as was the game and in particular player preparation or rather the lack of preparation. John Atkinson retired from rugby after that Vigo inspired John Player defeat to Wigan as he finally conceded his police career was preventing him maintaining his previous standards. Fortunately for Leeds that decision was reversed for a time shortly after following a change in shift patterns and he managed to eek a little longer out of his excellent career - probably long enough to see off the South African's short-lived Wigan career befor spells with Swinton and Oldham (?)

Give the ball to 'Atky' in space anywhere on the pitch and it was a virtual guarantee of three points - ask him to put his body on the line in defence though and the reverse was almost as true. A flailing high shot being typical fare.

A few years before that game there was a leeds wigan game at Headingley and Stuart Wright got in the clear and a wigan fan confidently shouted out"you wont catch him, you wont catch him"he didnt manage to shout a 3rd time before Atky cought him

Yes I was at that game too and saw those trie's.I remember most of all after the game Billy Boston come across from his wing to shake hands with a young 17 year old Delmos Hodgkinson.I was just turned 10 years old and the crowd was so large they moved us kids from the old dressing room corner to sit on the straw in front of the southstand.When I think of that game I wish I could have been a bit older so I could appreciate and remember more about it.I enjoyed reading that thread about the 50 odd years ago games on yours.I would have made a few contributions,but your resident Gauliter wont let me on

Called it!