Wigan vs St Helens- expect losts of moaning if the venue does not come up to the fans expections.
IMO Doncaster would be OK for Leeds and Cas.

I doubt it.

The attendance at the SF last year was 15,267 with an embarrassing closed stand. That's against Saints who, like us, have a lot of casual supporters who attend the big games in a season (like a cup semi). With respect to Cas, they don't have many of these kind of supporters as over the past 10 years, they've not been in any big games.

There have been some odd locations for semi finals over the years (Swinton in '84 was a disgrace). A footy stadium would seem to be the solution here.

Much better these days IMO to take these type of games to venues that could potentially sell-out and create a demand.

The atmosphere at the Halliwell-Jones on Saturday sounded electric. Wish I'd been there.

The half empty KC stadium appeared flat as a fart (on TV) by comparison.

True, but a variance in the buoyancy of mood at the clubs involved over the two games should probably be noted. If the mood at the KC was a little subdued that could be understood.

Yes that's a fair point also.

Saturday's atmosphere reminded me of the Leeds V Bradford semi-final at the McAlpine in '99 in the game to decide the eventual winners of the cup. Similar scenario given Wigan and Warrington's seasons to date.