Quote: BrisbaneRhino "Of the 10 losses in 2007, only 2 were lost by more than 10 points -5 of the losses were by 5 points or less. Even a blind man can see that even if not entirely in top form, we were highly competitive in virtually every game that year. The results (culminating in an absolutely dominant GF win) don't bear up at all some kind of tailing off in 2007.'"
If we're now contributing points difference statistics to argue our cases, here's my offering.
Leeds points difference under Smith tailing off
2004
Leeds were not on a relative high at the time Smith's departure was announced, despite your arrogance in suggesting he decided to leave on a relative a high at a pre-determined future point in time.
Quote: BrisbaneRhino "He won 2 GFs in 4 seasons'"
And McClennan won 2 GF's in 3 seasons.
Quote: BrisbaneRhino "and we were runner-up in another year.'"
There are no prizes for coming second.
Quote: BrisbaneRhino "In the salary cap era that's a tremendous achievement'"
In that case, McClennan's achievement must be viewed as sensationally stratospheric in comparison.
Quote: BrisbaneRhino "I have no doubt Smith probably left at the right time - for both himself and the club.'"
Agreed, his time was up at the club and a fresh approach was required. Just a shame he moved on to overseeing the most embarrassing international tour of Australia in the history of the sport, despite leaving no stone unturned in his preparations.
Quote: BrisbaneRhino "Bluey also did an excellent job in not messing around too much and winning us a further two GFs. Certainly the best coaching performance at Leeds after Smith over the last 30 years.'"
Or, more accurately, McClennan coached the club to the same amount of silverware in half the time it took Tony Smith.
Quote: BrisbaneRhino "I wouldn't trade a few better performances this year (or last) for any of the GFs we won, assuming that would have been the trade-off (i.e. starting to dismantle the side in 2009). That's whining loser talk.'"
The side wasn't dismantled in 2009. Quite the "Magnificent Seven" reverse. Why would dismantling the side in 2009 be considered a trade-off anyhow?
Quote: BrisbaneRhino "What I want to see is us move forward as a club - at the moment I see nothing to suggest McDermott can be the coach to revamp the side and get us back challenging for trophies.'"
Indications are that he's not the right coach for the job. However, he has been dealt a lousy hand of cards which a more gifted coach would struggle to convert into a winning hand.