Quote: west_leeds_rhino "I think the difference is the quantity of people in the crowd chanting, the intention of the crowd and whether the it is obvious that the person the chants are being directed at will take offence to it.
No club is a saint. Every club has it's fair share, it's possibly just the ratios that make the difference.'"
I know what you mean about the ratios but I don't see any difference between a section of the Castleford support directing a homophobic chant at Gareth Thomas and most of the Leeds southstand directing a chant at (say) Sean Edwards insinuating that he enjoys anal sex - a common enough chant over the years with its homophobic overtures, and directed at whoever was the play maker of the team we were playing that week.
Where Cas got shafted by the RFL was that it was directed at a high profile recent international RU convert who was also had a high international media profile regarding his sexual preference (see the coverage of his "outing" from America on Youtube) and it was televised/recorded, they were made an example of but they are not the only club who have been guilty of such things in the past.