Paul Prendiville-terrible winger.

Shout.

Wayne gets points for starting the grand tradition of large, cumbersome forwards outpacing Saint Helens' fullbacks.

Simon Irving

Andy Hay

Simon Worrall

from the 50s Jimmy Dunn,Malcolm Davies, Derek Davies,Jack Sewell

One for Damo... Jordan Tansey.

McDonald and Feather worse than Jamie Mathiou!?! You have got to be kidding. Both of those played quite big roles in the 2004 title winning season, each scoring some vital tries. They were in the team that handed Saints their ar$es 70-0, and both got a bad press because they did not run their weight. They certainly did not run in with all their weight, but were both fairly effective (if never to be great) forwards. Mathiou on the other hand, bar 1 break at homme to Wigan in which he put Frannie Cummins under the sticks, and one try away at Warrington? (Help tvoc!) was poor, in a poor Leeds team. I don't want to bag ex players too hard, but he was certainly worse than the two you mentioned!

Like G1 says, since Hay etc left in 2002 you'd struggle to name a really poor player that has consistently played. Even the likes of Anselme and Worrall have looked alright, even though they were fill ins, the quality of the side probably dragging their performances up.
Again do not wish to bag ex players, but how Tom Bush ever got a game for Leeds RL first team I will never know. He was to small, didn't have enough pace (see getting run down by James Graham at Knowsley Road one season) and had an awful habit of getting taken into touch.

3 from top of my head
jamie mathou
mark ONeil
Chris feather (just seemed a shame that someone with all the physical size seemed to have the heart the size of a pea!)

Most signings from 86 through to 92 were absolute pants.

Disagree with anyone for including Slammin' Sampson Neale Backo though.

His try at the death in the YCC SF at HQ against the Book burning Cod Smelling 'Tards from Umbersard in 1988 gets him Legend status in my book!!!

The frustrating thing with Feather was that there were a couple of games, or possibly parts of games, where he seemed to come out fired up and angry (PMT possibly?) and chuck his weight around a bit. His defence was still runnish, but at least he was an effective ball carrier then. Sadly for every 15-20 minutes of that there were about 7000 minutes of failure to live up to potential. I often wondered what would happen if you could have cloned Darren Fleary's brain and transplanted it into Chris Feather.