With regards to the club call, perhaps picking Wigan might be the better call, giving them Warrington in the final? That perhaps a better option than picking Warrington, suffering a bruising encounter and losing a few bodies for the final.

Personally I think the club call thing needs changing so that Saints can't pick Warrington to avoid the possibility of another round of Saints vs Warrington and Wigan vs Leeds.

(all this assumes Wigan and Warrington get through to the next round, which might not happen).

I completely agree. The unfortunate only other option is that you can't pick the team you played previously, which sort of takes the meaning of it away and could actually make it harder for you to get to the GF.

"Club Call" is a concept designed to create some media coverage of the week 3 playoff games, that's all.

I can almost understand it applying to the League Leaders as an additional reward for finishing top of the table, but it shouldn't then be "passed down" to the team that finished second just because the League Leaders lose their week 1 game.

Highest ranked team in week 3 should be at home to lowest ranked by right.

I'm a little confused that it passes to Saints. I agree that it should be added bonus for the team finishing top. I would add that if they lose game 1 then "club call" disapears. There is barely any advantage to finishing 1st compared to 2nd as it is. Club call helps, but only if you win your first game. The major benefit for us finishing top last year was shutting up Stains fans for a couple of weeks before the GF. I suspect that was a major motivation at the club as well.

The worst one for that was after Tomkins second try. He puts the ball down just to the side of the posts, but outside them. On the TV you can see Terry the Fish point to the spot as he awards the try. The kick is then taken bang in the middle of the sticks.

Not a big deal, but the refs do need to keep an eye on it.

Maybe Phil Bentham told Alibert he was wrong, despite the incident happening right in front of his eyes and him making a decision on it accordingly.

Wouldn't be the only time in that game, would it?

Now now Andy, stop making accusations about those nice referee people



GCH did point out that they seemed to be far more strict about this in the second half.

i think wigan wll get beat by kr

I think Wigan will win by 15-20.

I agree with Wilko i think HKR will win.

Isn't it the touch judges responsibility to mark the point of the try being scored and stand there until the kicker has taken the mark in line with the TJ before the TJ takes up his position behind the sticks?

That's how it used to operate on conversions at least. (Perhaps with the introduction of in-goal judges at the majority of games they've taken on the role (which would make sense) except obviously there are no in-goal judges at Sky games and that might create confusion amongst the officials.)

__________

If Hull KR (Dobson) can bring their 'A' kicking game with them then they have a chance in a low scoring game to knick it.

If they don't and they lose the territorial battle then I think Wigan have the greater fire power.