Last time we lost to Giants in Super League, we snaffled up their young, talented, exciting coach. I really rate Brown - he has got the very best out of a reasonable but not brilliant Giants team and their defence is second to none. When is McLennan's contract up and would people like to see Brown as his successor?

There is plenty more Brown's over in Australia.

What has Brown achieved then that McClennan's not?

Your user name is we love bluey yet yer trying to get him replaced already??


Keep the faith in Bluey mate we've been through worse in the past.

What had Tony Smith acheived prior to his appointment at Leeds?

Success wise? as much as his predecessor at Leeds.



Or did you forget that one before posting?

He got a fully professional Huddersfield promoted in a mostly part time league

Forget what?

I never mentioned his Leeds predecessor. I asked a specific question "What had Tony Smith achieved prior to his appointment at Leeds?"

The discussion will go further and be a little less like an LSD trip if you answer the questions that are put to you rather the questions that are going around in your head.

Your questions are like most your posts, Pointless!

The thread was about McClennan been replaced by someone. Therefore I asked the OP, what has Brown acheived that McClennans not to understand that argument.

You brought up the irrelevant subject of Smith, nobody else.

Again, in English please?


But it is very relevant. If you think previous achievements are an important criteria for appointing a new coach why is the question of Smith's previous achievements not relevant?

Do you not think it demonstrates that hetherington is prepared to employ someone based upon potential or based upon what they've shown with a "lesser team"? You know, like the OP was hypothesizing with Brown and like I took the discussion further with Smith?

Oh, and btw, you really should start reading threads before posting your nonsense on them. The OP brought up the subject of Smith so it was very relevant.

Looks like someone’s mounting a serious challenge to overtake G1 as the most respectable poster on these boards. Could be a thrilling few months in store on here

Did I really say it in that context? Did I? Did I bollox of course, but as I said above you jump in foot and mouth too early.

Smith replaced someone who had not won anything as a coach. On the other hand this time, why would we replace the most successfull coach this club has had with someone not successfull?

You really don't see the difference in scenarios?





That is a good point. Maybe you should try posting on a thread that it is relevant to. Unfortunately not this one.