if Smith leaves then yes, if Smith stays then he'll be a strong reserve and i'd take him over Ablett all season long.

His hat trick at Hull KR last year shows some of his potential when fully fit

The Potential he [uhad[/u, that's the problem how much damage have the injuries done?, You can't really on that one game...

No true that was one game and you cannot keep harping back to days gone by. At some point he has to be judged on the here and now.

Someone at the Rhinos obviously thinks he is still going to be good enough and, on tonights evidence, I thought he did well and kept Watuira largely quiet.

I guess time will tell!

Exactly so take yer own advice!


How long did it take the like's of diskin,jjb and scruton to show their true worth again after major injuries and long lay off's??
Gibson deserve's at least till the end of the season before anyone write's him off or calls for him to be ditched.
As for donald is it really just because he's been switched from left to right and has a different centre partner that his form is sketchy???

Gibson - What does he offer ?? - silky smooth hair.

Why play him at centre?

Because he's worth it...

Pity we cant magically combine Gibsons defence and reading of the game with Watkins attacking threat, step and offload ability.

Maybe GH is spending his money on working on a machine to do that instead of spending 100k on Gleeson

I wouldn't spend 100p on gleeson!!
Over-rated imo and anyone who backs his own team to lose is a c#*t!

mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm



Must be head and shoulders.

Seriously though i thought he was solid today, nowt spectacular but ran the ball in and did everything that was asked of him.

You're just sore because the club binned you so you dont get to wash the kit anymore.

Gibson had a good game tonight.