I love the cup the excitment waiting for draw etc you dont get that in play offs or sl.
Super league is a joke anyway why worry about losing 1 game cause it doesnt matter anyway just play well in 6 games at end of season.
Hence why saints had no threats of putting out a acdamy team to play catalan.
I just been watching a very enjoyable game of rl involving a nl club and sl team lot better than most of games of super league this year.
If leeds was in the nl it'd be all we'd be talking about playing super league teams why take out the lower teams chance to play big guns.

If anything the cup shows us what we need to do to develop the lower leagues which rfl ignore and make no effort to help them.

So Les Cats winning is because of the cup? They beat Salford 3 weeks before the game against Saints and ran the Saints team close over the easter weekend earlier in the season having played and having to travel to France just like St Helens so just because they won (oh the shock of them winning!!) that is another reason to scrap the cup?

Now you just look desperate.

Facts my good fellow mere facts

Saying that, Wigans domination of the cup way back when wasn't any good for the game either, if the RFL further developed NL teams and helped them all go full time and got the standard up to a low level SL team - Hudds for example - then the cup would be a more competitive altho not likely to throw up many sides from NL1 2 and beyond winning it, it sure would improve it

Develop the teams to improve the cup don't just rid RL of what is the most Historic cup in the sport

Make the SL team wear those bicycle cranks a la 'Its A Knockout'

Should do