Wrong.

From Operatrional Rules Section E

[iIn determining the appropriate sanction the Tribunal will take into account all relevant aggravating and mitigating factors (see below).

2.3 AGGRAVATING FACTORS
Previous Record
Violence
Retaliation
Injury caused
Incident not part of play
Other aggravating factors[/i

Its the worst challenge since Cassidy did Morley in 1998, absoulutely disgusting, the worst bit is that after he does it he looks back at the Fev player with a smug face. Absoulute coward of the highest order. 6 games minimum, if I remember correctly Cassidy got 8.

It did look a bit like one of Skerretts routine challenges , but they were ok werent they troll

Sorry Gronk, but if that's a shoulder charge then Rangi's shoulder is in a different place to mine. If first contact was with the shoulder it was certainly followed a fraction of a second later by something bonier (elbow or forearm is hard to tell) which was delivered with follow-through. Very poor IMO. Disciplinary will be looking at it I'm sure.

What I can't believe is that when we all see that either in slow mo or normal speed, it looks really bad, and when Chase looks down at him afterwards certainly doesn't help, but what puzzles me is, where was Thaler? How come it was not pulled up, was he not watching the game, in the case of Sam Moa, it looked bad, it was bad, and the officials saw it, Chase's was worse, and I can't believe not 1 official picked it up.

As much as i think Chase is a quality player that challenge was down right disgraceful, how anybody can even say he went in with his shoulder is beyond me, he clearly went looking to take his head off !!
And then just the way he looked down at him afterwards was like he was making sure he wasnt getting back up

utter crap just big hit, shoulder charge!! timed to perfection should have done it in the first ten not once the game had gone!!!

Ohh Cronk will like you...

Where is Cronk by the way, appears to have gone missing

Skool innit

he may have a thing called a job!! its what us grown up's do!! to pay tax to keep u on here all day!!

What a beautifully simplistic view of the working man.