yeah precisely. As I say I'm not slating the lad, he's a decent player and I hope he is good for you. But in terms of adding value to your squad.... I wouldn't have your club down as the type who are in real need of a utility player really

Money perhaps, but there are other things such as our stadium (one of the best in the competition) and probably the derby game. Lot's of players would love to be involved with those. As for why we keep taking kids from cas, let it be a complement to how well you're producing players even if you can't keep hold of them

No-way will he be shown the door, his def was a bit suspect when he came but he is getting better with every game. If he can get a injury free run we will see what he can produce, pretty excited for the future.

Don't think he is going to Hull FC

People keep going on about why us hull and hull kr getting players of each other is the distance of travel no youngster wants to leave home at 20 so they go to a club what is not hard travel to which is 1 of these 3 clubs. Has for hull youngsters if the first team coach does not give them a chance to come through It looks like the Acadmey not working but looking at the young full back and others what have come through the system it must be working so need to keep signing our youngsters.

Robin

God i hope your right, will free up some space one the cap and on the treatment table

Looks like the Walker to HKR prediction is correct :- www.thisishullandeastriding.co.u ... tory.html#!

Looks like the Walker to HKR prediction is correct :- www.thisishullandeastriding.co.u ... tory.html#!

If you're referring to wacker then I wish someone would do a count of minutes spent on the pitch cos he rarely did more than 15/20 mins per game last year. He's another player I really wanted to do well, but for whatever reason, he's dropped off and the aggression/tenacity appears to have gone; perhaps a change of scenery is what he needs; good luck wacker.

he has suffered from three knee reconstructions, for me he never got over the first one before he was playing again against the Giants, where he ruptured it again, & then again this season, what is a shame for a young lad with so much potential.

If he is going to KR & he finds his form you will have a good player, but since his injury he hasn't sown any real form, but a change of clubs could change his luck, & playing alongside his brother could spark I'm on.

I can remember when we brought Mason to Cas I thought we would have been better served by Jonathon's brother.

Agree with that Frank. Adam Walker has had a great year at HKR.

With three serious knee injuries already at a very young age,no surprise that Hull FC had second thoughts and other clubs will now be sceptical about signing him.

@HDMsport: #HullKR have signed Castleford prop Jonathan Walker on a three-year deal. Full story and interview in today's Mail.