Sometimes he is good, often ok, a lot better than me, but then again it's not my job is it? The phelps tackle was high, but he was not standing upright and that just deserved a penalty.

Some poor decisions and the Briscoe try did show him up for position and pace.

The obst assault was just that, no point, nothing to be gained, nothing professional about it, I would find that cheap at any level of the game.

5 games plus ban I would suggest and I won't complain at that. I don't buy in to this blackmail and owed business.... Decent bloke and when his head is on he can be a really positive contributor, but too often head not on right it seems.

But as others say, he keeps getting his name on the team sheet..... I think in the back 3rd of the season, TM has played what he has, sometimes out of loyalty or sometimes out of desperation to salvage something from the start we had.

Like i said earlier in the thread....send him to a shrink, its not like he can't afford it ...or get shut!

edited for accuracy

Its in our blood to try and defend one of ours,sorry,not this time,Ryan,take a good,long hard look at yourself and try to find out why,in you're mind,it's ok to try and incapacitate a fellow player,you have issues,serious issues,please sort it out before someone gets really hurt.

Compounded by the fact Obst is one of the smallest and honest players in the game. He must have looked at him and thought you are everything I'm not and lashed out like the thug he is.
I've held back having a go at him as I don't mind a little biff but that was just an assault.

Anythings possible, but until or if it happens he's your problem not ours - there's a good lad.

Sam Obst is a better golfer than Ryan may be he took him out because he cant beat him at golf either

I must say I'm surprised at the Cat B rating for the offence, carrying only a maximum of two games.

It was a late, deliberate short-arm to the head. The sort of cheap shot that breaks players' jaws.

McGoldrick can count himself a very lucky chap

Lucky is not the word !!!!!

Let him off ffs,its obvious he did nothing wrong.

Let him play against us saturday.

Mcgoldrick suspended for Saturday, thank god.

Phew!!! That's at least 3 less penalties we'll concede, without Ryan McCompletedick on the pitch.

Amazingly the report describes it as a major blow to Cas's chances against Hull KR. The reporter's obviously not seen his recent games then!

We have bemoaned the lack of consistency in grading and sanctions from the RFL this season and (much as criticising one of our own doesn't seem right) this again is a rank mis-judgment.

The 'tackle' and contact on Obst was deliberate, calculated and targetted at the head, so for that to be a Cat B offence and 2 matches is stupid. I don't mind McGoldrick, I would love to have half the talent he does - but it had nothing to do with Rugby League, it was pointless and cheap and what protection does it offer kickers if this is only 2 games.

I would suggest if that 'tackle' had been made on Rangi Chase by a Hull player, we would be highly upset by the sanction and our coach would have somethig to say about it.

My thoughts exactly - the glib responses of some people on this thread are rather distasteful, given the severity of McGoldrick's attack on Obst.

Once again, with this and the Hock decision, the RFL have shown a total disregard for player welfare.

Mcgoldrick deserved more than 2 games. I cannot work out that disciplinary panel