That together with the "colours rule" in some pubs makes Edinburgh less special. Take it back to Cardiff!

We should be on our way back from twickers about 12 noon, back in cas for about 2ish, Let me know where your going mate, ill probably join you

I hope the magic weekend is at another city next year....how about Newcastle?

Villa park is a tidy ground and Birmingham city centre has been redeveloped,thing is would the Lancashire teams just do day trips in?

While Nottingham has good nightlife the City ground is no better than Elland road and has the city got a high crime rate?.

Think Newcastle would be ideal, St James park is within walking distance of the city centre,plenty of pubs and restaurants.
Also accomadation wouldn't be a problem in the area,and great nightlife

Problem with Newcastle and Birmingham is they are not tourist places so would there be enough hotel spaces for the influx of 40,000 rugby fans.

With Newcastle you have all of the North East for places to stay as well as the city...Durham,Whitley Bay,North and South Shields etc

Then there is Northumberland if you want to stay in areas more picturesque

Have you ever tried to get somewhere to stay in Newcastle on a weekend without a rugby tournament on? Its nigh on impossible.

Yes,managed it four times.

I wouldn't say Cardiff was a tourist hotspot but people worked round that by staying in South Wales or as i did for one of the Challenge cup finals down there stopped in Bristol and got the train in. So by getting the north east tourist board involved (Ive have seen the t.v advert) that would help.

Wherever the next location is to be, it doesn't have to be chosen on which city is the greatest up! True, lots of people enjoy this part, but the whole concept wasn't thought of so that we can have an excuse for a lads weekend away. The idea behind it all is to take the game on the road and have a show piece event outside the heartlands of RL and to promote the game and give other people the chance to sample our product.

Of course there are lots of people who wish to get tanked up, and so places such as Dublin are being mentioned. But on the other side of things, there are lots of fans like me who do not look for a good old drink and simply want to watch the rugby. If Dublin is chosen, it almost certainly cuts out fans such as me, whereas somewhere like Newcastle makes it a definite for me and fans of my sort. Dublin is straight away a £200 plus (even more if you take family) trip as opposed to a "fill up the car with juice and off you go" trip to Newcastle. I attend 99.9% of all Cas games, with the usual CC final, Grand final and a few international fixtures chucked in every season. Yet out of four magic weekends i have only made [ione[/i day trip to Cardiff. Yes i could have driven to Cardiff again and Murrayfield twice, but personally i chose to keep my money in my pocket for once.

A big factor with myself and i guess some other families is that RL takes up lots of weekends. Not everyone in my household like to go to the rugby all the time and so when another £200 plus weekend pops up i usually end up spending that £200 on my other family members and doing something with them for a change. So as i say, for people like me places such as Dublin will be write off in my RL calender whereas somewhere closer to home such as Newcastle or Birmingham will have my support all the way. The RL have to remember not to cast off fans like me when they chose the next venue otherwise they'll be scratching their heads as to why they only get 25,000 fans each day.

Here here Marshy

my 2 pence is Would it not be better if we had the event as a season opener, Most fans miss there Rugby while the close season is on so would jump at the chance to visit a stadium and see all SL teams 1st w-end of season .
Newcastle also get my vote but a football stadium during the season might be a big ask!!

Problem with doing it at start of the season is Finances.

the new season starts in february which means if you have an opening weekend event when would you have to book hotels etc. Possibly January even December. Not sure about you but i am normally skint in those two months what with presents and paying the impending credit card.

south of france / northen spain ?

It's just a shame Villa Park is 30 minutes from Birmingham City Centre on public transport... people complain about Murrayfield being too far away from the centre of Edinburgh

The concept is good, but how cold would that be. Cold enough to put me off sitting all day. No ta.