Not really...

I don't need to stoop to speculation about what we might and might not have done last season. It was you that came up with the comment about "you would of lost all the game you did despite who was playing" despite STILL giving no good reason at all for why you think this is the case.

If you seriously think we're a one-trick pony team, then you don't know a thing about Cas Tigers - Chase has rightly taken a lot of the limelight (and I suppose that having read the papers and listened to the commentators, all you're doing is recycling the hearsay), but with players like Huby, Arundel, Clark, Orr, Milner, good kicker in Dixon, Emmitt, Owen, Ferres, Walker we've clearly got one or two players who can produce the goods. However, why let facts get in the way of a good soundbyte?

You still can't back up your speculation (labelled as "FACT"icon_wink.gif and you still fail to show that you understand anything about Castleford's performance last year. Your arguments are wafer-thin and simply don't hold up to the lightest of scrutiny. The only player you seem to know even a little about is Rangi Chase, and despite your assertion that we "would of lost all the game you did despite who was playing", you've not given any reason why. Which replacement players do you think were as good as the original squad players, and why?

a) our performances weren't ridiculously bad last season - they were about as bad as we expected them to be, given the position we started in and the scratch squad we had assembled; that's why beating you at your place and Shudds at ours were met with such enthusiasm.

b) is a 'high and mighty stool' what I do on a Saturday morning after a heavy night on Ossett Brewery's finest?

c) no we didn't.

You have been on playground duty too long...talk about "My Dad is bigger than your Dad"

Could you and the rest of the Wakey troll squad give it a rest for, oooh a week at least?.

Like i said on a previous post you have made some good signings but will we have to put up with more posts like this until February

Precisely.



I think it's pretty clear to everyone that you did. If you didn't, please explain how!

I thought you were bored with that discussion?

Back to Tadulala (as the subject heading says), unless he is early twenties and a forward, we aren't signing him!

I am but it sounded like you had something constructive to share, for a change. Obviously now that you don't we can do this

If you want to re-hash a discussion from 6 months ago, feel free to delve into the archive of the WTW forum to find all the posts that I and various other people made about the franchise decision at the time it was actual news; I certainly won't be doing it for you.

I agree that my posts often warrant a second or even third reading; with that in mind, knock yourself out.

Even on a pay as you play deal I don't think he would be any better than what we have. Would be a backward step IMO.

12 pages about Semi Tadulala? Even allowing for the usual diversionary postings from Wakey fans that seems disproportionate.